Pages:
Author

Topic: [ANN][Blocknet] truly decentralized exchange | token ecosystem infrastructure - page 89. (Read 1103293 times)

hero member
Activity: 771
Merit: 521
Quick update: Testing is in full swing and appears to be going very well with various currencies and various users testing out different trade combinations.
member
Activity: 116
Merit: 10
Quack.


true 0/

just a thought of mine - if blocknet is a Blockchain to Blockchain trading platform - how does the transaction time work?

say for example i want to exchange BTC for LTC. Blocktimes/Confirmation times are different so im locked until ive got my coins? (to trade further) also who does pay the transaction fee for the trade? (BTC and LTC)

i mean if i want to buy a coin because i believe in it longtherm its a great solution because i dont have to trust a central authority but if i just want to daytrade or scalp the markets im way better with polo/bittrex/whatever?

thanks!

synechist from the dev team answers this in the Reddit Blocknet AMA, here's the piece discussing your question - https://www.reddit.com/r/theblocknet/comments/676buj/ask_anything_about_blocknet_qa/#bottom-comments

Quote
Several people have asked what the speed of the decentralised exchange is, and how it will be affected by heavy volume, so I'll put that down here as a question.

[–]synechist 2 points 1 month ago
The capacity of the Blocknet's decentralised exchange increases with its user base. Since order broadcast and order matching are completely decentralised, there are no bottlenecks other than the ones which lie with users, namely their local internet connections.
In addition though, there is a shared capacity in the broadcasting system, which is really sky-high. Here is a relevant quotation from a Bitcoin wiki (https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Scalability#Scalability_targets):
Quote
Network Let's assume an average rate of 2000tps, so just VISA. Transactions vary in size from about 0.2 kilobytes to over 1 kilobyte, but it's averaging half a kilobyte today. That means that you need to keep up with around 8 megabits/second of transaction data (2000tps * 512 bytes) / 1024 bytes in a kilobyte / 1024 kilobytes in a megabyte = 0.97 megabytes per second * 8 = 7.8 megabits/second. This sort of bandwidth is already common for even residential connections today, and is certainly at the low end of what colocation providers would expect to provide you with. When blocks are solved, the current protocol will send the transactions again, even if a peer has already seen it at broadcast time. Fixing this to make blocks just list of hashes would resolve the issue and make the bandwidth needed for block broadcast negligable. So whilst this optimization isn't fully implemented today, we do not consider block transmission bandwidth here.
Finally, there is an inherent limitation in the blockchains traders choose to use which affects the time between trading coins and re-trading them, which is the blockchain's confirmation time. Thus, if a trader wishes to trade Bitcoin at a "trustless" (well, widely regarded as non-risky) level of security, (s)he should wait an hour before re-trading an address. However, I have proposed a solution to this, in the form of a "0-conf slider" in the UI, which functions to filter orders according to the number of confirnations that the user is willing to wait for. Thus, at a small increase of risk, scalping and other fast trading strategies may be employed.
I think that suitably addresses concerns. The Blocknet is fast.

Hope this helps!

thank you!

what exaclty is the risk? is there a more technical explanation? also - when im trading with coins i dont have a confirmation to spend on, how does blocknet or my bitcoin/litecoin wallet block the coins not to be spend elsewhere? as i understand i will need the full blockchains to do transactions. so i guess the blocknet client is executing transactions via my btc/ltc client?

86B
jr. member
Activity: 45
Merit: 1


true 0/

just a thought of mine - if blocknet is a Blockchain to Blockchain trading platform - how does the transaction time work?

say for example i want to exchange BTC for LTC. Blocktimes/Confirmation times are different so im locked until ive got my coins? (to trade further) also who does pay the transaction fee for the trade? (BTC and LTC)

i mean if i want to buy a coin because i believe in it longtherm its a great solution because i dont have to trust a central authority but if i just want to daytrade or scalp the markets im way better with polo/bittrex/whatever?

thanks!

synechist from the dev team answers this in the Reddit Blocknet AMA, here's the piece discussing your question - https://www.reddit.com/r/theblocknet/comments/676buj/ask_anything_about_blocknet_qa/#bottom-comments

Quote
Several people have asked what the speed of the decentralised exchange is, and how it will be affected by heavy volume, so I'll put that down here as a question.

[–]synechist 2 points 1 month ago
The capacity of the Blocknet's decentralised exchange increases with its user base. Since order broadcast and order matching are completely decentralised, there are no bottlenecks other than the ones which lie with users, namely their local internet connections.
In addition though, there is a shared capacity in the broadcasting system, which is really sky-high. Here is a relevant quotation from a Bitcoin wiki (https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Scalability#Scalability_targets):
Quote
Network Let's assume an average rate of 2000tps, so just VISA. Transactions vary in size from about 0.2 kilobytes to over 1 kilobyte, but it's averaging half a kilobyte today. That means that you need to keep up with around 8 megabits/second of transaction data (2000tps * 512 bytes) / 1024 bytes in a kilobyte / 1024 kilobytes in a megabyte = 0.97 megabytes per second * 8 = 7.8 megabits/second. This sort of bandwidth is already common for even residential connections today, and is certainly at the low end of what colocation providers would expect to provide you with. When blocks are solved, the current protocol will send the transactions again, even if a peer has already seen it at broadcast time. Fixing this to make blocks just list of hashes would resolve the issue and make the bandwidth needed for block broadcast negligable. So whilst this optimization isn't fully implemented today, we do not consider block transmission bandwidth here.
Finally, there is an inherent limitation in the blockchains traders choose to use which affects the time between trading coins and re-trading them, which is the blockchain's confirmation time. Thus, if a trader wishes to trade Bitcoin at a "trustless" (well, widely regarded as non-risky) level of security, (s)he should wait an hour before re-trading an address. However, I have proposed a solution to this, in the form of a "0-conf slider" in the UI, which functions to filter orders according to the number of confirnations that the user is willing to wait for. Thus, at a small increase of risk, scalping and other fast trading strategies may be employed.
I think that suitably addresses concerns. The Blocknet is fast.

Hope this helps!
hero member
Activity: 771
Merit: 521
member
Activity: 116
Merit: 10
Quack.
New update:

There is another update coming this week, with the focus being on the updated api and orderbook.  There will be active trading tests via “bots” on testnet.
The update will be tomorrow and the goal is to have the bots working by the weekend.

Internal testing on the service nodes will also begin by the end of the week (this is an alpha release only).

thanks for update
future looks rosy

I trust exchanges less and less

polo banned trollbox, go by trollboxes on btce etc , there are literally dozens of people daily ruining polo, how funds got stolen, no support
matter of time before it is the next cryptsy

livecoin is a good exchnage but there are zero details on there. nothing, complete strangers, could do a bunk any day
gox etc

I lost some funds on couple smaller exchanges safecex lol and allcoin

when blocknet is fully up and running soon , people are going to wonder how they managed without

exchanges will still last, centralised as many dont want fixed price trades they want the pumping and dumping

blocknet will also be perfect for whales and new money wanting big trades at fixed prices and secure escrow sales

I see blocknet $60-80 range inside next 4-6 months


true 0/

just a thought of mine - if blocknet is a Blockchain to Blockchain trading platform - how does the transaction time work?

say for example i want to exchange BTC for LTC. Blocktimes/Confirmation times are different so im locked until ive got my coins? (to trade further) also who does pay the transaction fee for the trade? (BTC and LTC)

i mean if i want to buy a coin because i believe in it longtherm its a great solution because i dont have to trust a central authority but if i just want to daytrade or scalp the markets im way better with polo/bittrex/whatever?

thanks!
sr. member
Activity: 371
Merit: 252
full member
Activity: 141
Merit: 100
The only exchange i trust now is bittrex, but do not ask me why, just feeling! I took all my money from poloniex just because they had too much problems, probably i am not right and poloniex is perfect, but weeks over weeks of waiting to get an answer for a ticket, problems everywhere, banned trollbox because of bad athmosphere, (nothing else i think,) is not a good sign for the future!

Time for Blocknet to come up! Everyone i his own exchange!


HODL Block!
legendary
Activity: 1061
Merit: 1001
New update:

There is another update coming this week, with the focus being on the updated api and orderbook.  There will be active trading tests via “bots” on testnet.
The update will be tomorrow and the goal is to have the bots working by the weekend.

Internal testing on the service nodes will also begin by the end of the week (this is an alpha release only).

thanks for update
future looks rosy

I trust exchanges less and less

polo banned trollbox, go by trollboxes on btce etc , there are literally dozens of people daily ruining polo, how funds got stolen, no support
matter of time before it is the next cryptsy

livecoin is a good exchnage but there are zero details on there. nothing, complete strangers, could do a bunk any day
gox etc

I lost some funds on couple smaller exchanges safecex lol and allcoin

when blocknet is fully up and running soon , people are going to wonder how they managed without

exchanges will still last, centralised as many dont want fixed price trades they want the pumping and dumping

blocknet will also be perfect for whales and new money wanting big trades at fixed prices and secure escrow sales

I see blocknet $60-80 range inside next 4-6 months
hero member
Activity: 771
Merit: 521
New update:

There is another update coming this week, with the focus being on the updated api and orderbook.  There will be active trading tests via “bots” on testnet.
The update will be tomorrow and the goal is to have the bots working by the weekend.

Internal testing on the service nodes will also begin by the end of the week (this is an alpha release only).
newbie
Activity: 35
Merit: 0
I don't understand. They do the same thing? They are direct competitors? https://nvo.io/index.html

No.

One doesn't do anything except sell its tokens for their future exchange.

The other is currently live on testnet, mainnet soon.

OK. The thing is, I do not know much English and sometimes it's difficult for me to understand all the information. Thank you for explaining. But I like Blocknet and I regret that I did not learn about it before. Now I can not buy enough coins to be enriched in the future. But I will still support this project. He has a good future.
sr. member
Activity: 371
Merit: 252
I don't understand. They do the same thing? They are direct competitors? https://nvo.io/index.html

No.

One doesn't do anything except sell its tokens for their future exchange.

The other is currently live on testnet, mainnet soon.
newbie
Activity: 35
Merit: 0
I don't understand. They do the same thing? They are direct competitors? https://nvo.io/index.html
sr. member
Activity: 274
Merit: 251
full member
Activity: 141
Merit: 100
Yes, its planed for third week of July, but could take few days longer...
hero member
Activity: 560
Merit: 500
So main net launch is july/august?
hero member
Activity: 539
Merit: 500
sr. member
Activity: 476
Merit: 250
Blocknet is looking much more good day by day at value and popularity because of timing when people really need some fully decentralized exchange. I am happy my little amount is becoming much more valuable. It deserves to reach at $100 due to limited supply.

Indeed.  GDAX(coinbase) went down again during a selloff and the amount of people left twiddling their thumbs while the world burned around them is a lot more than the other times too.  This may turn out to be great timing for Blocknet to introduce that new marketing team and put them to work  Grin
NrX
sr. member
Activity: 770
Merit: 254
Blocknet is looking much more good day by day at value and popularity because of timing when people really need some fully decentralized exchange. I am happy my little amount is becoming much more valuable. It deserves to reach at $100 due to limited supply.
sr. member
Activity: 476
Merit: 250
@Optimiza that's the experience I hope to have - is this possible? I am not sure how the DX will work exactly from the user viewpoint

With Jaxx-wallet the idea is partially there so far, however it has limited coins, does not connect to hardware wallet, and the exchange is made using Shapeshift.  Wallets like these could fall within the Blocknets scope, although maybe blocknet may end up being a specialized exchange service (i.e. one of the wallets 'apps').  More ambitiously, the end product I see would be something like the Ethereum Mist Browser, except the Browser is blockchain specific, whereas this general purpose software would be multi-blockchain.  I haven't found any project like this out there (except Jaxx and hardware specific lite clients like Trezor, but  how do you invest in them?); blocknet comes nearest to the above vision from the projects I know.   

Think of Blocknet more like bitorrent.

It is the architecture linking everything together. Truly peer to peer, which means you can use whatever wallet and coins you want and access any of those coins features/advancements/perks through what Blocknet is enabling. No more bitstamp or bitfinex holding your private keys, losing funds, stealing, etc.


(official Blocknet please correct me if i'm wrong though. Most of the articles I read that explained that are pretty old now.)
Pages:
Jump to: