I was totally with you until this part. People mined Karma because it was, and still is, a kick ass coin with 1 minute block time that started with massive early bonuses. It was a miners dream mixed with a really great name and mission!
100% with you. Karma was, and still is, awesome!
But you should know that probably 90% of the miners out there don't give a shit about any coin but BTC and maybe one or two "pet" alts. They mine what is profitable and sell. If they can exploit a weakness/bug/hashrate advantage to make even bigger profit, most of them won't think twice. And while I am sure most miners are regular guys, have solid ethics and wouldn't ever dream of consciously damaging a coin, there will always be some that won't have a problem with it. The altcoin space is not called wild west without reason. There are heroes and there are bad guys. Just look at all the horrible scams, hacks, ddos attacks etc.
Let's say I was one of the early recipients of the new mega powered scrypt ASICs, and I point my new weapon at the Karmablockchain. I immediately start doing 25-50-75% of all of the hashing. I am providing a service to the network and helping the KARMs flow throughout the web. I collect 25-50-75% of all the blocks. I immediately dump them? Sit on them? Sell part of them? Not sure what the big deal is or the threat that is coming. If you can cite an example of the threat I would like to read more and share with the team.
3 words:
Time warp attack"The time warp attack[1] is based on a bug in Bitcoin and Litecoin (and their forks) where the difficulty calculation is off by one block. This is an example of a flaw that affects all coins, especially ones with low network hash rates. " -
Litecoin Wiki
Several coins have been hit by time-warp attacks already. I know at least one was attempted against UNO lately (though apparently it was unsuccessfull). Terracoin is a pretty well known example, check this discussion on it from "Let's talk bitcoin". Really, listen to it. The basic set up is very similar to the situation Karma and other Litecoin clones will be facing soon.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t8ffDIw0J3QThe relevant part is from 0:20 - 11:53
A quote from the show, right after they discuss the attack, how it happened, what made it possible to happen and how it could be prevented (from Andreas Antonopoulos): "Well, in this case, choosing SHA256 as a proof of work puts you right in the shark pool. [...] Use the PoW to carve out your own little swimming pool where you can survive [...] otherwise, the ASICs will come and swallow you."
"Scypt 2014" === "SHA256 2013"
Would someone invest $12k in the latest ASIC card to mine something and then fork the coin to oblivion? Doesn't make sense to me. Normally someone investing that kind of money is fairly disciplined, intelligent, and is going to put his money to work in the most efficient, responsible manner.
Yes of course someone will get the idea to fork a coin into oblivion. Why wouldn't they if it makes them fast and easy BTC? Don't get me wrong, I love your optimism, but under which rock have you been hiding? Do you not see the shit that is constantly going on around us in these very forums? There are plenty of wealthy people in this space that only care about one thing - profits. They don't care about any altcoin, some even don't care about BTC.
Will Karma be a target? Who knows - I sure hope not! But there WILL be casualties.
Loving the discussion, and I can speak for the team when I say, we always want transparency in all that we do. So please dont get down on any of this as indecision or confusion. We are all on the same mission here and have the same goals for this crypto and the community.
We have set a reasonable timeline to ensure that all options are considered and promise to be as transparent as possible.
Well then good luck to us all I guess. If we get through all of this unscathed I will make a nice donation to the Karmafund.