Rollback is a must.
Rollback will kill Komodo and SuperNET, we all know that, we're not too BIG to fail like Ethereum was.
Think carefully @jl777!
Topic: [ANN][KMD][dPoW] Komodo - An Open, Composable Smart Chain Platform, Secured by B - page 535. (Read 1192000 times)
March 13, 2017, 12:43:37 AM
Rollback will kill Komodo and SuperNET, we all know that, we're not too BIG to fail like Ethereum was.
Think carefully @jl777!
March 13, 2017, 12:43:05 AM
If we don't roll back we are only devaluing the whole ecosystem...How many coins do we think he/she got?
If an equivalent amount is burnt from the dev premine it's basically paying the attacker a bug bounty from dev funds, all other investors are no worse off.
Rollback is thermonuclear option, it can KILL komodo and SuperNET today!
Paying a bounty to a guy who found dangerous bug is well worth it IMO
KMD was headed down the Coinmarketcap list already. This will probably bump it out of the Top 50, but maybe it was inevitable.
Although some of that selling was probably the hacker, dumping coins.
March 13, 2017, 12:39:39 AM
If we don't roll back we are only devaluing the whole ecosystem...How many coins do we think he/she got?
If an equivalent amount is burnt from the dev premine it's basically paying the attacker a bug bounty from dev funds, all other investors are no worse off.
Rollback is thermonuclear option, it can KILL komodo and SuperNET today!
Paying a bounty to a guy who found dangerous bug is well worth it IMO
March 13, 2017, 12:36:51 AM
is that the same bug as Zcoin had ?
u are freaking kidding me
anything Z related seems to turn into crap
u are freaking kidding me
anything Z related seems to turn into crap
March 13, 2017, 12:20:08 AM
If we don't roll back we are only devaluing the whole ecosystem...How many coins do we think he/she got?
I did not count, but about 5-6 millions.I have a suggestion for the devs. For the first year KMD is out, we can predict maximum amount of KMD in the system (discounting not claimed or not converted BTCD). We can also get total supply out of the block explorer. How hard would it be to compare the difference each block and hook it up to a Big Red Alarm?
March 13, 2017, 12:18:54 AM
An attacker has taken advantage of an exploit and is generating coins. We made a new version that would stop this at 236000 but the attacker ramped things up to levels that will force us to rollback the chain to 235300.
Please do not do any transactions until we get a new version out that solves this.
more details after this attack is over
Please do not do any transactions until we get a new version out that solves this.
more details after this attack is over
Attacker found a bug, let him keep the coins as a reward. Rollback is last resort, unless he got 5% of coin supply or more, rollback is far worse outcome.
Remember BTER hack ... no rollback from NXT devs was right decision then, and is right descision for komodo now.
Hacker did a service finding bug ... let him keep the coins, please!
Edit: Komodo classic would be a disaster!
There wont be Komodo classic. Komodo is a work in developmnent. No one has got the resources enough to keep the original komodo chain (komodo classic) working. Even if someone tries to launch komodo classic it will be DOA because the hacker will generate unlimited amount of coins on that older chain.
Rollback is a must and there will be only one komodo.
March 13, 2017, 12:12:54 AM
If we don't roll back we are only devaluing the whole ecosystem...How many coins do we think he/she got?
March 13, 2017, 12:07:13 AM
Rollback is a must.
March 13, 2017, 12:06:26 AM
Shit, just found 234899
Looks like it's being going on for awhile now.
https://kpx.io/blocks/000000948c2b637a756b30d7ac4933cf225f5fd7253b6da3d02c1aeeee2bbdab
Edit: I can also see some other strange miner rewards like
35 https://kpx.io/blocks/0d224faa66493534de582f4f4587196ab99195c327ee97bfdc4456ceb818bbe9
55 https://kpx.io/blocks/00004b1ad20f3aba90cec87553aecbc2e1b0797f599b7a59e72338d408dbe1f6
79 https://kpx.io/blocks/098f7967f9fd497bdb4ad4da33b389099312787ec434678c02852eeb161a8a36
Maybe this has been going on for a long time? Looks like it's being going on for awhile now.
https://kpx.io/blocks/000000948c2b637a756b30d7ac4933cf225f5fd7253b6da3d02c1aeeee2bbdab
Edit: I can also see some other strange miner rewards like
35 https://kpx.io/blocks/0d224faa66493534de582f4f4587196ab99195c327ee97bfdc4456ceb818bbe9
55 https://kpx.io/blocks/00004b1ad20f3aba90cec87553aecbc2e1b0797f599b7a59e72338d408dbe1f6
79 https://kpx.io/blocks/098f7967f9fd497bdb4ad4da33b389099312787ec434678c02852eeb161a8a36
March 13, 2017, 12:04:04 AM
The first block with 100k looks to be 233559
https://kpx.io/blocks/00000001f828f9e031cbe45768f454f93ed6b629ef3809de16f9674be3ab6efa
Checked till 228000 looks clean, if anyone want to continue - be my guest.
There are millions of KMD generated, negotiation is not in question here. Blockchain should be rolled back.
https://kpx.io/blocks/00000001f828f9e031cbe45768f454f93ed6b629ef3809de16f9674be3ab6efa
Checked till 228000 looks clean, if anyone want to continue - be my guest.
There are millions of KMD generated, negotiation is not in question here. Blockchain should be rolled back.
March 12, 2017, 11:54:04 PM
An attacker has taken advantage of an exploit and is generating coins. We made a new version that would stop this at 236000 but the attacker ramped things up to levels that will force us to rollback the chain to 235300.
Please do not do any transactions until we get a new version out that solves this.
more details after this attack is over
Please do not do any transactions until we get a new version out that solves this.
more details after this attack is over
Attacker found a bug, let him keep the coins as a reward. Rollback is last resort, unless he got 5% of coin supply or more, rollback is far worse outcome.
Remember BTER hack ... no rollback from NXT devs was right decision then, and is right descision for komodo now.
Hacker did a service finding bug ... let him keep the coins, please!
Edit: Komodo classic would be a disaster!
March 12, 2017, 11:42:16 PM
Exploits have been taken advantage but dev it aware of it . Anytime soon it will be addressed with a solution. Price may affect negatively and holders are advised not to engage any transactions before the fixed has been implemented. Meanwhile, got to get ready for dumps at the exchanges.
Thanks for your advise March 12, 2017, 11:40:08 PM
Will there be masternode?
March 12, 2017, 11:32:50 PM
Shit, just found 234899
Looks like it's being going on for awhile now.
https://kpx.io/blocks/000000948c2b637a756b30d7ac4933cf225f5fd7253b6da3d02c1aeeee2bbdab
Edit: I can also see some other strange miner rewards like
35 https://kpx.io/blocks/0d224faa66493534de582f4f4587196ab99195c327ee97bfdc4456ceb818bbe9
55 https://kpx.io/blocks/00004b1ad20f3aba90cec87553aecbc2e1b0797f599b7a59e72338d408dbe1f6
79 https://kpx.io/blocks/098f7967f9fd497bdb4ad4da33b389099312787ec434678c02852eeb161a8a36
Looks like it's being going on for awhile now.
https://kpx.io/blocks/000000948c2b637a756b30d7ac4933cf225f5fd7253b6da3d02c1aeeee2bbdab
Edit: I can also see some other strange miner rewards like
35 https://kpx.io/blocks/0d224faa66493534de582f4f4587196ab99195c327ee97bfdc4456ceb818bbe9
55 https://kpx.io/blocks/00004b1ad20f3aba90cec87553aecbc2e1b0797f599b7a59e72338d408dbe1f6
79 https://kpx.io/blocks/098f7967f9fd497bdb4ad4da33b389099312787ec434678c02852eeb161a8a36
March 12, 2017, 11:30:11 PM
So that guy with 2.5 million:
is hacker that inject new coins?
I think he started generating them at block 235252is hacker that inject new coins?
https://kpx.io/blocks/000000715aec8ae14905db00b5fb0eb7453ff9c987c9ac8e75de84345fb5d4ae
Looks like a first fake transaction with generation of 100003KMD
James, make it 235000
Good news is every bug that's fixed makes the coin stronger.
March 12, 2017, 11:29:17 PM
No wonder the price of KMD was in decline.
Rollback and get rid of the scammers coins.
Rollback and get rid of the scammers coins.
March 12, 2017, 11:24:15 PM
So that guy with 2.5 million:
is hacker that inject new coins?
I think he started generating them at block 235252is hacker that inject new coins?
https://kpx.io/blocks/000000715aec8ae14905db00b5fb0eb7453ff9c987c9ac8e75de84345fb5d4ae
Looks like a first fake transaction with generation of 100003KMD
James, make it 235000
March 12, 2017, 11:22:06 PM
So that guy with 2.5 million:
is hacker that inject new coins?
is hacker that inject new coins?
March 12, 2017, 11:09:54 PM
Is that the 100k guy? Quick reaction from Bittrex.
ADD: Can anyone explain to me what is he doing right now? I see he is sending fake coins out hidden, but what's the point? If chain is getting rolled back, it's just a waist of time. Isn't it?
ADD: Can anyone explain to me what is he doing right now? I see he is sending fake coins out hidden, but what's the point? If chain is getting rolled back, it's just a waist of time. Isn't it?
March 12, 2017, 11:04:35 PM
Exploits have been taken advantage but dev it aware of it . Anytime soon it will be addressed with a solution. Price may affect negatively and holders are advised not to engage any transactions before the fixed has been implemented. Meanwhile, got to get ready for dumps at the exchanges.
Jump to: