Well after using the pool for over 24hrs and previously posting about how I like the pool sadly this will be the last time I use it. After A full day of mining with 5.1-5.7 Mh depending on temps I ended up with 0.04883982 BTC. Thats over 50% less than just mining LTC alone. Why is the pool spending all its time mining coins that are not anywhere near the highest profitability? Several times that I checked we were mining coins less profitably than LTC which as we all know is nowhere near the top of the list. If market depth on coins being held in your exchange hot wallet are preventing the pool from mining coins that are truly more profitable than this pool needs to work out its strategies. The profitability switcher needs some serious work. The auto trade feature is nice but if I just took the actually alt coins and traded them myself right away I would have made more BTC. I think you guys need to dump the coins asap for whatever you can get for them instead of hoping to maximize the trade value over a few days since it doesn't look like the miners here see the benefit of you trying to sell high.
1) Yesterday was our second worst day on record
2) A coin that says its most profitable on external site A, but we find would NOT be if we dumped our pool earnings, who is right? We could dump before anyone mining it gets a chance, in which case it wasn't the most profitable for them by the time they got any coins to trade
3) We had 2 coins disabled (CAP and CGB), both of which are often near the top of the charts throughout the day. Both are re-enabled at this point. The CGB was particularly costly, as we had a few rounds worth of it orphan out on us, meaning we lost any profits there.
4) If you are basing profitability solely on coinchoose, its not always as quick on diff changes (from my personal experience, nothing against the site). If you have your own or other sources, so be it.
5) We do take stalerate/past performance into account. Some coins, while showing as 'most profitable' ended up not being so once we got the final BTC back. Some examples, GDC, ALF, KGC, EMD, DMD...all of which we have since moved on from mining because of this.
6) Sometimes a small increase in profitability difference isn't worth switching for, so we don't. Not sure if this fits any of your examples though.
7) We do dump coins rather quickly (in my opinion), and rarely are things left over a matter of days. I agree with you you'd likely end up ahead if you just kept the coins and traded yourself, and I think you'd find that with any auto-trade option out there. This is precisely why we give miners the flexibility to do it.
@ 5.5Mh/s you should earn 5.2LTC/day = .0878 BTC. Still not a profitable comparison for us, but not over 50% either. As I said, it was our 2nd worst day in 2 weeks of operation.
At any rate, I'd say in summary, try us out for a longer period than just 24hrs (a particularly rough 24hrs), but that is up to you. I appreciate you checking it out, I know you hit up my other pools often as well.