How does the current limiting on the PCIe plugs work, BTW? I'm not at home to check, but I would assume that the two plugs are not simply paralleled on the hashing board and that each 12V plug powers two of the ASICs in a loop.
IE, if you disabled a full loop on a hashing board you'd pull full power from one plug, and ~0W from the other.
Is that correct?
the sp20 seems to be 1 plug per loop. so if you knock a plug loose on 1 board(each board has 2 loops) the board only allows 1 loop to work. this is good and it is safe.
I have knocked loose a pcie cable at the psu end and the sp20 just ran 1 loop on that board.
problem is that the S5 will put about 270-320W per blade, so if you use two seperate cables thats a managable 150W/cable. If one fails, that 300W will push a cable to its limit. 16awg can handle that but an 18awg will certainly fail.
in comparison, the SP20 can draw up to 288W PER CABLE at full speed. (~150W/cable underclocked). Not much difference in safety as far as I see, if anything the SP20 is more likely to cause PSU failures (in lower quality supplies).
dont use a Bronze or lower PSU for either device, thats my suggestion. GOLD or PLAT power supplies will have better safety features and use thick wiring in its cables. Alternatively, I sell 16AWG PCIe cables that have either a connector on each end, or a connector at one end and stripped wires for server mods on the other. Ive used them to carry up to 312W each at which point they get warm but not hot
using Corsair CX750M on S5 at 325 setting (disliked the sound of fans at 350) and regular fan (Vornado) blowing in the same direction as the internal fan, temperatures (other than boards) were measured by the laser probe:
Ambient 27-28C
miner boards temp 48-49C
hashing at ~1070Gh/s
Connector at PSU- 29C
First 10-15 cm of wire-33C (interesting!), the rest of the wire 28-29C
Connector on S5 closest to the internal fan-29C
Connector on S5 farthest from internal fan-33C (interesting)
each branch of the branched PCIe is connected to the same board (same side of the miner)
this looks safe at least as far as at connectors temperature is concerned
later I will test with 325 and no external fan, then 350 with an external fan, then (maybe) 350 without an external fan