Topic: [Discussion] Bitcointalk Community Awards 🏆 - page 28. (Read 19698 times)

I am personally glad that there are people on this forum who are not afraid to say what they really think, regardless of the fact that it may concern some who think that they are some kind of gods of the forum and that some special rules apply to them.


Your idea is good because it does not require intervention by the admin, but since there will be those who will not read the rules and will make this fatal mistake (maybe accidentally) and thus be disqualified, it would certainly be better to merits be completely disabled in that thread. Either way, some of it would be desirable to apply.

---

What is really incomprehensible to me is that someone is pressuring to publish the final results, and does not show even the slightest empathy for a person who is fighting with his family for life in a country attacked by his compatriots. I hope he gets his reward as soon as possible and stops whining in this thread.

I don't think this will reach the top of theymos' Todo list. I've seen suggestions to add more control over which Ranks can vote, but that hasn't been implemented either.

It's technically possible to implement such thing. But the real question is whether theymos will implement such thing, especially when new forum software is in development (although no one knows when will it be ready)?

Good, idea but was that ever done before? I mean wouldn't that mean theymos would have to intervene and make this specifically for this contest? Imho, more elegant solution would be to simply disqualify anyone that merits the voters, like @GazetaBitcoin and few others suggested. In the end, it goes in line with bitcoin philosophy about personal responsibility.



In some others forums that I am active on and that are much older than bitcointalk they have the option to make poll voting public, so everyone can see who voted for who. Would something like that be possible to implement here as well, forum software wise?

That's a terrible idea: anyone can vote on a poll, which makes (alt) abuse very easy.

I think it's a very interesting idea. And it can even help to reduce the likelihood of ties arising. In addition to even being able to facilitate who does the collection of votes. Having the specific name of the candidates, the vote can be in poll format and that makes everything simpler and more practical.

I fully understood your point of view, Lucius, as I read your previous posts and I share most of your thoughts. I am sure that icopress also understands you and never thought you would blame him. Practically, the situation that happened was like this: Zeus gave fire to Prometheus, to give it to people thus people would use it to get themselves warm and cook their food, but people used the fire to burn each other's homes. icopress did his best to organize a very complex competition, spent a lot of time to think about categories, eligible voters, contest rules etc., he tried to entertain the forum, in a way, but some took all his efforts as an opportunity for personal benefits.


I am glad my idea has fans and, as I see, you and icopress are two of them. However, if the contest is kept on Ivory Tower board and if it will have a rule to disqualify any user which would award votes, then there would not be necessarily needed to disable merits in the respective thread. If any merit occurs, the respective user is disqualified and, I think, this will be more harsh for him / her.

---

I am sorry that you forgot to vote, Welsh...


Certainly, the problems can be mitigated. We can all learn from first two editions of the contest and make the next one greater

---

And another suggestion I'd like to make, for the next iterations of the contest, is to have two phases during the contest: a first phase where all eligible users can vote any users they want and a "play-off", where top 5 users of each category are qualified. In the second phase the voters can nominate only users which qualified in the play-off. I think in this way the contest would raise even more interest and it will be more spectacular.

I forgot to vote. I actually intended on voting in some of the categories this year, just things got in the way. Although, I definitely think there's been a few problems with the current format highlighted, and I believe for most of them they can be somewhat mitigated for future additions. I do think there was more interest in this years competition than the previous year, even without all of the controversy surrounding certain voters.

Pretty much every single industry I've worked in outside of this forum, at some point in the process someone is cheating. I could probably count on one hand theThe major reason is a lot of people are motivated by money, which usually means they try to make as much of it as possible, and while merit might not be obviously linked to money, it definitely helps certain users with certain goals.

I also hope that some lessons have been learned from the previous two competitions, in which I unfortunately did not vote for some of the reasons I have already explained in some of the previous posts. Just to clarify that I do not blame @icopress, but individuals who, due to their personal interests, made this competition very questionable.


I fully support this idea, and I would also suggest disabling the merits in this thread in order to prevent competitors from motivating voters in this way.

I think that we learned something from these two contests and, probably, from next edition, icopress will make some changes (assuming that he will still keep the contests going -- of course, with administration's support as well). I advise that one of the changes to specify that all the users voting on any post will be automatically disqualified (in case they will be nominated by someone). In this way, we can avoid all the drama (and / or abuses?) that took course on this contest and, if I remember well, on the previous one as well.

Another suggestion that I am making is to take the contest to Ivory Tower board, thus ensuring that no members with ranks below Full Member are able to interfere. This way we will avoid a good amount of spam. Indeed, this would mean that members with ranks of Newbies, Jr. Member and Member will not be able to vote, no matter if they have more than 50 votes, but, considering the very low amount of such cases (during actual contest we had less than 5 such users, if I remember well) this would not be a problem.

The voting has been closed on 3rd March, and I haven't found anyone else with similar activity. However, there was few more entries from ineligible forum members. All of those posts are deleted now, but some of those ineligible voters has received merits.

Simply they were trying to receive merits. Those votes will not be counted (based on the rules), and they aren't going to be picked for the prizes draw. Those users has successfully received merit from their voting posts. User preikaler is a great example of those abusers.

Why is humans like this? We tend to be lawless and unnecessarily smart. Infact I wouldn't know what to say about this. Why should someone want to vote twice? Is it that some persons have decided not to be law abiding that they will like to cheat every process?
Why this kind of behaviour? Is it as a result of personal wish or environmental influence? I am surprised how humans can actually be.

The other time it was people commiting plagiarism in voting by copying verbatim Ratimov vote and pasted it, I couldn't stop laughing 

Thank you for bringing this up. I analyzed your mentions and this is what I found:


mumang siat's vote will not be taken into account, as he has less than 50 merits.


Mups099's vote will not be taken into account, as he also has less than 50 merits.


sifat08's vote will not be taken into account, as he also has less than 50 merits. Now he appears wil only one vote, therefore he deleted one of his submissions.


wtsimis appears with only 1 vote now. As long as he submitted the vote after having 50 merits (and he did so), his vote is valid. He has 59 merits now and he had 51 when he submitted his (actual) vote.

If you find any other inconsistencies feel free to highlight them as well.

It saddens me to see how indifferent people can be to someone else's suffering. Now I see a similar situation in Ukraine, as Russian-backed forces and pro-Russia sympathizers terrorize people and use violence and intimidation to further their goal.

The Russians have their own tragic history of aggression against foreign countries, but there's no denying that their efforts to destabilize Ukraine are for political and economic reasons. I don't have words to describe the hypocrisy of their arguments.

Those people opposing Russian aggression are not just fighting a battle for their homeland. They're fighting for all of Europe, and the future of freedom!

Same for me. The war is not in my country yet, but I understand that it will be here (I am from the country of the aggressor - Russia, and I understand how it all ends). My DNA is changing because I don't understand how the whole world allows this to happen - in the middle of Europe, a terrorist country is trying to destroy another country.
No one is taking any real emergency measures. I'm scared to imagine what consequences all this will have - now everyone clearly sees that it's enough to be strong and you can do anything - rob, kill. And as long as you're strong, everyone else will just look at it.

Yeah I know, I didn't turn on my laptop for more than 2 months due to real life business. I only checked my profile occasionally without logging in via mobile, until I found the words like "News: vote for bitcointalk community awards" under my profile picture a few days ago and bookmarked it which I thought it was an interesting event with many sponsors.

Man the thread was created on 25^th of Jan which means you have 37 days for the voting and it hardly takes few minutes to cast your vote and still you are saying you are late? If you have been following the thread you could have done it earlier but now there's no chance.

I can feel your pain mate and it's really heart breaking to see a beautiful country has now turned to be a devastated land and how much pain the local residents must be feeling.Have 2 known ones obet there gone for medical studies and can feel how much the bad the situation is there from their talks
so be strong.But i truly appreciate your efforts and all other Ukrainian people's who stood unite in this difficult hour with their country and against the Russian army.Preparing food, shelter for family and giving training to people for all the petrol bombs is inspiring for all of us.

This award results can wait but at this time we all stand with you and Ukraine as morale support so all the best and be safe man.

Oh no, is it really closed to new voters? I've been paying attention to that thread for the past few days and intend to vote today. Unfortunately, I was late.


Sorry for what happened in your country, my friend.
May safety be with you and your family.

Trust me when I say I understand exactly what you're going through right now. I'm from Croatia, and I'm old enough to remember what it was like for us 30 years ago.

Keep your family's safety in mind, and ignore everything else. If you ever need shelter, know that you are always welcome in Croatia.

I feel very honored by the fact that icopress asked for my help on this matter and I am more than happy to help. For me is a sincere happiness that I can give him a hand of help, especially in such situations. I would have felt happy to help him also outside the actual actual world context, due to the deep friendship and respect between each other, but right now the feeling I have is way deeper.

Be well, my friend, and do all you can to keep your family alive! I pray for all your people to be well. And, in case you ever think about this -- Romania is welcoming all Ukrainians. There are already thousands here, all received shelter, food and good treatment. A mobile company is also offering free calls to and from Ukraine. In case you feel it's too dangerous for your family in Ukraine, you can safely suggest them to come here. I know you, as a man, are not allowed to leave the country, but women and children can do it.

If I can help with anything more please let me know. All my good thoughts are sent towards you.

And, as I already told you, you are a hero, icopress! A real world hero! I bow down in front of the actions you do for saving your country, family and people!