Author

Topic: MtGox withdrawal delays [Gathering] - page 313. (Read 908613 times)

legendary
Activity: 1792
Merit: 1059
August 15, 2013, 04:12:41 PM
If Bitstamps price is pure illusion what you call CAMPBX price or BTC-E?

Irrelevant.

CAMPBX
-----------
FIAT: 86,282$
BTC: 1,255฿
USD/BTC-ratio: 69$
Source: http://campbx.com/api/xdepth.php

BTC-E
-----------
FIAT: 42,288$
BTC: 277฿
USD/BTC-ratio: 153$
Source: https://btc-e.com/api/2/btc_usd/depth
full member
Activity: 182
Merit: 100
August 15, 2013, 03:42:58 PM
Please, anybody standing in the withdrawal queue before me, could you panic, too? So the queue shrinks and I get my money? ;-)

Things weren't right. I had withdrawals from about a month ago that went trough 10 days ago. Another withdrawal from just one day later in july is still in the queue. So either

1) They are not processing in order
2) They haven't processed *anything* since that particular day.

Enough for me not to trust them. I really feel like Gox needs one more push and it's all over. (like one more agency/swift bank/whatever giving them a hard time)

Lost 10% of my value, but then again, I sold some BTC for € on Gox when the price was already higher than everywhere else  Smiley
hero member
Activity: 531
Merit: 505
August 15, 2013, 03:39:56 PM
Please, anybody standing in the withdrawal queue before me, could you panic, too? So the queue shrinks and I get my money? ;-)
full member
Activity: 182
Merit: 100
August 15, 2013, 03:36:50 PM
I have a number of SWIFT (€) withdrawals pending, 3 digits, most from end of july, beginning of august.
[...]
What should I do?
SEPA is much faster than SWIFT at the moment for EUR.  SEPA queue is actually getting shorter.  If you can't wait a week or two for your money, there are a few other options giving much better prices than Bitstamp, which I consider the panic option.  E.g. sell BTC locally for cash via Localbitcoins.com.

I couldn't stand it any more and panicked out Smiley Bought BTC with my € for the ridiculous GOX BTC price, got those BTC outta there and transfered to euro via another Exchange.

Really, Gox, I hope you burn in hell for this. (or worse)
legendary
Activity: 3878
Merit: 1193
August 15, 2013, 03:35:19 PM
As painful as this delay has been for me (still waiting on my June 26 withdrawl from MtGox), it's good for the economy. Having only 1 primary exchange is trouble. It's good to see BitStamp volume equal to MtGox. I'm enjoying CampBX with low fees and quick withdrawls, so I hope their volume improves too and I can send more business their way.
legendary
Activity: 1638
Merit: 1001
₪``Campaign Manager´´₪
August 15, 2013, 03:25:42 PM
Bitstamp is only used for withdrawals  No man invested money there. No one.

So yeah, that's complete bullshit.  Please explain to me where the money is coming from that is being withdrawn.....
legendary
Activity: 966
Merit: 1001
Energy is Wealth
August 15, 2013, 03:25:04 PM
Coinbase - No Gox
Bips - No Gox
BitPay - No Gox
blockchain - No Gox

've never dealt with them. Would never sell below the Gox price. I can get-off all my money via SEPA from Gox. No problems here. Had my last withdrawal started on July 24 and it's already on pending. So it has lasted less than a month. This is perfectly fine for me if I consider the whole comfort that I have with Gox.

A service that is not based on Gox is IMHO ridiculous. The Bitstamp price is a pure illusion. The mass will never get this exchange rate. Never. Not in weeks, not in months, not in years. Never. Without Gox we are single digit again. The course breaks down as soon as people try to withdraw their money.

The Bitstamp ratio is at 52$ and there are only a Million Dollar in the order book for months! Bitstamp has permanently an exchange rate which is much higher than there ratio. Why? Because it is only used for withdrawals  No man invested money there. No one.

If Bitstamps price is pure illusion what you call CAMPBX price or BTC-E?
legendary
Activity: 1792
Merit: 1059
August 15, 2013, 03:07:40 PM
Coinbase - No Gox
Bips - No Gox
BitPay - No Gox
blockchain - No Gox

've never dealt with them. Would never sell below the Gox price. I can get-off all my money via SEPA from Gox. No problems here. Had my last withdrawal started on July 24 and it's already on pending. So it has lasted less than a month. This is perfectly fine for me if I consider the whole comfort that I have with Gox.

A service that is not based on Gox is IMHO ridiculous. The Bitstamp price is a pure illusion. The mass will never get this exchange rate. Never. Not in weeks, not in months, not in years. Never. Without Gox we are single digit again. The course breaks down as soon as people try to withdraw their money.

The Bitstamp ratio is at 52$ and there are only a Million Dollar in the order book for months! Bitstamp has permanently an exchange rate which is much higher than there ratio. Why? Because it is only used for withdrawals  No man invested money there. No one.
legendary
Activity: 1437
Merit: 1002
https://bitmynt.no
August 15, 2013, 02:54:19 PM
Please enlighten me where I can exchange at Gox price?  

Hmm and lets look at the top merchant processing in the Bitcoin marketplace (because that is what drives the Bitcoin economy) and see what they use for pricing:

Coinbase - No Gox
Bips - No Gox
BitPay - No Gox
blockchain - No Gox
I never used any of those, and have no idea what their references are.  If any.  I tried to check Bips, and the only reference I found on https://bips.me/pricing was MtGox.  Their API seems to require a key, and I couldn't be bothered to find out how to make one.
Because it is amazingly easy to sell at or above MtGox rates just about everywhere, except on a few exchanges.
Believe me, it is.
full member
Activity: 238
Merit: 100
August 15, 2013, 02:12:17 PM
Several of the people trying to escalate the situation by spreading rumours here, are busy taking arbitrage as well.
I admit that.
I don't see how you could take advantage of arb if you can't withdraw the fiat....
Because it is amazingly easy to sell at or above MtGox rates just about everywhere, except on a few exchanges.  MtGox is still the reference rate most places.  If you have a bank account in Japan there are no problems withdrawing either, but you will currently get 2.5% less if selling BTC for JPY on MtGox compared to USD.  SEPA withdrawals will go through as well, but there are still delays for SEPA withdrawal making it unattractive compared to the other options.  If you have money to place in medium term savings, you can deposit on USD MtGox via BTC at instant 10% profit.  Expect very competitive BTC prices on MtGox when their fiat withdrawal problems are solved.  I don't want to be out then.

Please enlighten me where I can exchange at Gox price?  

Hmm and lets look at the top merchant processing in the Bitcoin marketplace (because that is what drives the Bitcoin economy) and see what they use for pricing:

Coinbase - No Gox
Bips - No Gox
BitPay - No Gox
blockchain - No Gox

I find it hilarious that you think that Gox price is still relevant despite the mountain of evidence otherwise.
legendary
Activity: 1437
Merit: 1002
https://bitmynt.no
August 15, 2013, 02:07:45 PM
I have a number of SWIFT (€) withdrawals pending, 3 digits, most from end of july, beginning of august.
[...]
What should I do?
SEPA is much faster than SWIFT at the moment for EUR.  SEPA queue is actually getting shorter.  If you can't wait a week or two for your money, there are a few other options giving much better prices than Bitstamp, which I consider the panic option.  E.g. sell BTC locally for cash via Localbitcoins.com.
legendary
Activity: 1437
Merit: 1002
https://bitmynt.no
August 15, 2013, 02:01:16 PM
Several of the people trying to escalate the situation by spreading rumours here, are busy taking arbitrage as well.
I admit that.
I don't see how you could take advantage of arb if you can't withdraw the fiat....
Because it is amazingly easy to sell at or above MtGox rates just about everywhere, except on a few exchanges.  MtGox is still the reference rate most places.  If you have a bank account in Japan there are no problems withdrawing either, but you will currently get 2.5% less if selling BTC for JPY on MtGox compared to USD.  SEPA withdrawals will go through as well, but there are still delays for SEPA withdrawal making it unattractive compared to the other options.  If you have money to place in medium term savings, you can deposit on USD MtGox via BTC at instant 10% profit.  Expect very competitive BTC prices on MtGox when their fiat withdrawal problems are solved.  I don't want to be out then.
full member
Activity: 182
Merit: 100
August 15, 2013, 01:45:23 PM
Guys,

I have a number of SWIFT (€) withdrawals pending, 3 digits, most from end of july, beginning of august.

The way I see it, after reading all this, I have 2 options:

1. Ask for cancellation, buy BTC, get them off gox asap, transfer to another exchange, sell, take at least a 10% loss. (BTC 10% higher on gox)

2. Wait...

What should I do?

Also, more importantly, if I choose 1, what exchange do you guys recommend? Bitstamp? I just want these frickin' BTC converted to € and on my bank account.

Thanks
hero member
Activity: 501
Merit: 500
August 15, 2013, 01:31:38 PM
They could mail cheques drawn on Japanese banks to people in the US if they really wanted, but the customers in US would not like much the (very high) fees they'd need to pay in order to cash such a cheque in a US bank. If it's even possible, I do not know.

Plus, it's down right impossible to cash any bank cheque in much of continental Europe. I have never seen a cheque with my own eyes. In Europe, electronic bank wires (even between banks) have traditionally been very low cost, and with the introduction of SEPA, they're free. Anything that involves paper is very expensive.
full member
Activity: 238
Merit: 100
August 15, 2013, 01:29:46 PM
Several of the people trying to escalate the situation by spreading rumours here, are busy taking arbitrage as well.

I admit that.

I don't see how you could take advantage of arb if you can't withdraw the fiat....
full member
Activity: 238
Merit: 100
August 15, 2013, 12:30:50 PM
I do some research and found this site for example:

http://forum.gaijinpot.com/showthread.php?114083-Cashing-a-cheque

It seems that cheques in Japan as in Germany and in many other countries not to be common. You can not compare it with the Anglo-American world. Other countries normaly do not use cheques, more precisely: bank cheques. It would also not change anything. AML and everything else also applies to bank cheques. There are even more requirements for these cheques.

Hhhahaha wow, great investigative work with that forum thread!  Why the moderators still allow you to speak is unbelievable.  Worthless commentary. 
legendary
Activity: 1792
Merit: 1059
August 15, 2013, 12:15:56 PM
Actually in the UK they are still widely used. In fact they are probably the main way of making payment between individuals and/or small businesses that don't have card facilities (of which there are many).  I would certainly expect my bank to accept a cheque drawn on a Japanese bank, though there might be some fees involved. But it may be different elsewhere.

I do some research and found this site for example:

http://forum.gaijinpot.com/showthread.php?114083-Cashing-a-cheque

It seems that cheques in Japan as in Germany and in many other countries not to be common. You can not compare it with the Anglo-American world. Other countries normaly do not use cheques, more precisely: bank cheques. It would also not change anything. AML and everything else also applies to bank cheques. There are even more requirements for these cheques.
legendary
Activity: 1437
Merit: 1002
https://bitmynt.no
August 15, 2013, 12:12:08 PM
14:17 <@MagicalTux> when we were in the second largest bank in Japan, we represented more than half of all the volume of SWIFT processed by that bank (almost overloading their systems a couple of times)

I can see:
1. No mention of overloading computer systems.
2. No mention of a million SWIFT transfers every day.

Japan is economically very different from the rest of Asia.
Well it does not exactly say the word computer, but since they are also in the same quote basically claiming they sent about a million SWIFT transfers every day it pretty much confirms the obvious which is that it is computer systems and not manual systems this quote is talking about as the bank is not going to handle million transfers manually.
A million SWIFT transfers is some number you pulled out of your hat.  You imply the bank has several million large companies as customers.  This is not realistic.

A SWIFT transfer isn't much manual work.  Returns and rejects are.
Quote
Since they claim they represented more than half of the volume it means something in the range of million since the volumes at the bank are several millions.
Source?

Quote
I claim that my calculations make about sense and you are just refusing the interpret the quotes the obvious way without any kind of justification for that, just that you refuse to believe the obvious.
Here is another quote from IRC, which you conveniently ignored:
Code:
14:10 < sturles> MagicalTux: Why only 10 SWIFT transfers per day?  Is that commonplace for customers in your bank?
14:12 <@MagicalTux> sturles, most companies in Japan will do one, maybe two SWIFT transfers a month to providers overseas (actually most will do zero)
Do you really think the bank has more than 30 million companies paying via SWIFT (most companies will do none) as customers?  Assuming 2 million SWIFT transfers a day where MtGox has half.  Let me ask again: Can you provide a source for that number?  In most cases a simple payment by credit card or another method will do fine, and there is no need for a SWIFT transfer.  Not daily.  Not every week.  Not even every month for most companies.
Quote
And Japan is different from the rest of asia but in the direction that Japan has bigger percentage of banking functions than many other parts so the number of SWIFT messages processed are probably higher in Japan than my calculations show.
Or it could be that Japan, as a highly advanced and organized society, has more practical payment options available to them.  E.g. international credit cards with low fees.
hero member
Activity: 552
Merit: 501
August 15, 2013, 11:55:16 AM
What's stopping or making it difficult for MtGox to *create* those cheques and mail them out?

I really do not know what you're talking about. How to create a cheque in Japan which is accepted by a Bank in your home country? I would guess that this is impossible. I've never seen anything like that. This works within the European Union. But the banks take astronomical fees. And a cheque from Japan? Not possible. No Bank will accept this. You have to travel to Japan to redeem it.

It's much easier to open a bank account in Japan. Why are not doing that? You can get your money from Gox in ¥ if you need it so urgent. Dollar not possible, thanks to the FINCEN.  

Cheques are dead. Nobody uses cheques these days.

Actually in the UK they are still widely used. In fact they are probably the main way of making payment between individuals and/or small businesses that don't have card facilities (of which there are many).  I would certainly expect my bank to accept a cheque drawn on a Japanese bank, though there might be some fees involved. But it may be different elsewhere.
newbie
Activity: 49
Merit: 0
August 15, 2013, 11:53:42 AM
What's stopping or making it difficult for MtGox to *create* those cheques and mail them out?

I really do not know what you're talking about. How to create a cheque in Japan which is accepted by a Bank in your home country? I would guess that this is impossible. I've never seen anything like that. This works within the European Union. But the banks take astronomical fees. And a cheque from Japan? Not possible. No Bank will accept this. You have to travel to Japan to redeem it.

It's much easier to open a bank account in Japan. Why are not doing that? You can get your money from Gox in ¥ if you need it so urgent. Dollar not possible, thanks to the FINCEN.  

Cheques are dead. Nobody uses cheques these days.

I don't see how its impossible. I get foreign cheques from banks around the world and I cash them in at my bank just fine, there are some fees ofcourse but that's what i accept.

Cheques are very far from dead. Just because YOU may not use them does mean no one else does.

Google for example has paid me by cheque every month for the last five years. And i live in canada, Google sends me a US dollar cheque which i cash just fine.
Jump to: