I filed a ticket with Cryptsy. Any other advice would be appreciated. I live by the rule to not invest more then I can afford to lose but this is still almost a months salary.
Something similar happened to me when trying to transfer NXT from Cryptsy (not nearly as many). I only got it resolved by making the biggest stink possible here at bitcoin forum. Cryptsy doesn't like it when you openly talk about their problems on this board, so they get to your problem fast. There are people who have been waiting three or four months for their NXT deposits from Cryptsy. There is some kind of trouble, and for some reason Cryptsy won't fix it. All I can tell you is email and complain as much as possible.
edited to add: Here is the original post I made about my Cryptsy problems. https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.7728955