1 - Yes, in fact there are many who openly critizice the government, even in Youtube.
2 - No, adult Ruzzian are not free to oppose Putin, that is my point, they should and that is why Ukraine should not be under the Moscow regime.
3 - No, Snowden is not free to speak because he signed off not to do so. He is a spy, so not free to divulge any information (criminal or not) he got access in that capacity.
Many in Norther Ireland would disagree and many other would not. Scotland had their referendum and many overseas territories opted for independence without any fuzz.
1. Yes, you can do it on youtube. This is what happens when you do:
https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/e/7/233896.pdfYana, victim’s wife on SBU officials:
They have beaten him to death simply. When they came — they took him away to torture him. When they brought his body back — the heels were blue, the feet were blue.
He’s got some traces of punctures on his hands... I don’t know... what they did to him, punctured him or drove the needles under his nails — there were holes on his hands.
Each bone has a hole in it. They tortured him like... when there was a real war no one has tortured people the way they tortured him.
I guess its like Idi Amin said:
“There is freedom of speech, but I cannot guarantee freedom after speech.”
Oh, and I would believe you if I had not seen youtube channels, newspapers,... criticising the Ukrainian government, from Ukraine, with identified authors saying that Zelensky is not performing and not delivering.
Now, I read the report, which would need to be read along with the thousands of others, but it does not speak of systematic torture or state torture. Can you say honestly that filtration, torture and kidnapping are not a state policy in Ruzzia? I mean, if you want to trust eh OSCE...
https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/6/1/541623_1.pdfSummary: The event is devoted to the presentation of the report “NINE CIRCLES OF HELL. PLACES
OF DETENTION IN UKRAINE UNDER THE RUSSIAN OCCUPATION”. In the year since Russia’s
invasion of Ukraine on 24 February 2022, a constant flow of images and accounts has painted a
horrifying picture of the human rights violations and international crimes that appear to be strategies of
Russia’s war.
The report covers a wide range of places of detention, notably
penitentiary institutions (correctional colonies and pre-trial detention centers), police establishments and
social and healthcare institutions. In addition, it covers unofficial places of detention such as makeshift
torture chambers. Within these places of detention, the report documents numerous violations of
international human rights and humanitarian law, including torture and other inhuman or degrading
treatment or punishment, wilful killings and military strikes. Building on 725 documented episodes, the
report outlines key patterns and trends.
I am sure you understand what means "pattern", but just in case, it means many similar cases pointing to a common cause.
You are trying to make look the same things that are simply not the same. The level of freedom of speech in the west is 1000 times higher than in Ruzzia, or China or under any of your favourite dictators. It simply goes with the system - a dictatorship is weak by definition because it usually can only be ended by violence or death (with rare exceptions), so "speaking" puts the guy at risk of death. In participative systems, change IS the system, so speaking about change is everyday.