Author

Topic: ANTMINER S5: 1155GH(+OverClock Potential), In Stock $0.319/GH & 0.51W/GH - page 275. (Read 451048 times)

member
Activity: 89
Merit: 10
Where are you getting the pricing for the SP20?  Cheapest I can find is $633 each and that's if I buy their nano farm promotion.

https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/closed-sp20-most-efficient-miner-05wgh-2-units-min-903286

I confirmed this with SP and they are going to ship direct.

Sounds like the deal is over.  Was only for the first 200.  So back to what average noob home miner (like me) can expect, here's what I come up with.

                     S5     SP20
Cost (inc shp)     455       633
Hash Rate           1155     1700
Cost/Hash            0.39      0.37
Power                 590     1200
      
@1155 gh/s        455       430
24hr Pwr Cst       1.56   2.15
Pwr Savings        0.59   
      
Cost Difference      $25.00   
legendary
Activity: 3892
Merit: 4331
That's just based on the the following:

S5 (From Bulk Batch2): $384 +$30 (averge shipping from China to USA)=$414 per 1155G, 590W.

It's what I was told shipping would be on Batch 2.

bulk batch has no shipping charges, so you cannot really combine these two parameters, so it is $413+ $27-40/unit (if you order 2-6 units)=$440-453

I would have thought that too, but that's not what I'm being told. And if you go to the checkout part, you will see it adds over $1300 for shipping Sad

if it is so, then it is unfortunate.
legendary
Activity: 1218
Merit: 1001
That's just based on the the following:

S5 (From Bulk Batch2): $384 +$30 (averge shipping from China to USA)=$414 per 1155G, 590W.

It's what I was told shipping would be on Batch 2.

bulk batch has no shipping charges, so you cannot really combine these two parameters, so it is $413+ $27-40/unit (if you order 2-6 units)=$440-453

I would have thought that too, but that's not what I'm being told. And if you go to the checkout part, you will see it adds over $1300 for shipping Sad
legendary
Activity: 3892
Merit: 4331
That's just based on the the following:

S5 (From Bulk Batch2): $384 +$30 (averge shipping from China to USA)=$414 per 1155G, 590W.

It's what I was told shipping would be on Batch 2.

bulk batch has no shipping charges, so you cannot really combine these two parameters, hence it is $413+ $27-40/unit (if you order 3-6 units)=$440-453
EDIT: apparently the bulk shipping is NOT free  Huh for S5, so 384+25-30 appears to be right
legendary
Activity: 1218
Merit: 1001
Where are you getting the pricing for the SP20?  Cheapest I can find is $633 each and that's if I buy their nano farm promotion.

https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/closed-sp20-most-efficient-miner-05wgh-2-units-min-903286

I confirmed this with SP and they are going to ship direct.
legendary
Activity: 1218
Merit: 1001
That's just based on the the following:

S5 (From Bulk Batch2): $384 +$30 (averge shipping from China to USA)=$414 per 1155G, 590W.

It's what I was told shipping would be on Batch 2.
member
Activity: 89
Merit: 10
Where are you getting the pricing for the SP20?  Cheapest I can find is $633 each and that's if I buy their nano farm promotion.

Edit: And my S5 shipping to the states was $455.
legendary
Activity: 1274
Merit: 1004
So I'm reaching out to others for their take on the S5 vs SP20.  I calculate that it would take 125 days to recoup the additional electricity that you are saving with the S5 vs. it's premium over the SP20 when comparing equal hash rates and not taking into account the lower power draws of the SP20 when down clocked.

                                                                                     S-5                                    SP20
Cost (including shipping)                                                      414.00 $                              500.00 $ 
Hash Rate                                                                            1155                                   1700
Cost per Hash                                                                        0.36 $                                 0.29 $       
Power (watts)                                                                         590                                   1200
Watts per Hash                                                                0.510823                             0.705882

Comparable Costs @ 1155gh/s
Costs                                                                                     414                             339.7059
24hr power cost $.11/kwh                                                        1.56 $                                2.15 $       
Power Savings per 24hrs                                                          0.59 $       

Cost Difference                                                                     74.29 $     
# of Days to recoup Savings                                                124.911      

So unless I plan on keeping the S-5 longer than 125 days, it wouldn't make sense to get it vs the SP20.  Am I missing something?  Also this is using the 52 unit price for the S-5 vs. the single unit price of an SP20.

How are you getting the S5 for $414 including shipping?
legendary
Activity: 1218
Merit: 1001
So I'm reaching out to others for their take on the S5 vs SP20.  I calculate that it would take 125 days to recoup the additional electricity that you are saving with the S5 vs. it's premium over the SP20 when comparing equal hash rates and not taking into account the lower power draws of the SP20 when down clocked.

                                                                                     S-5                                    SP20
Cost (including shipping)                                                      414.00 $                              500.00 $ 
Hash Rate                                                                            1155                                   1700
Cost per Hash                                                                        0.36 $                                 0.29 $       
Power (watts)                                                                         590                                   1200
Watts per Hash                                                                0.510823                             0.705882

Comparable Costs @ 1155gh/s
Costs                                                                                     414                             339.7059
24hr power cost $.11/kwh                                                        1.56 $                                2.15 $       
Power Savings per 24hrs                                                          0.59 $       

Cost Difference                                                                     74.29 $     
# of Days to recoup Savings                                                124.911      

So unless I plan on keeping the S-5 longer than 125 days, it wouldn't make sense to get it vs the SP20.  Am I missing something?  Also this is using the 52 unit price for the S-5 vs. the single unit price of an SP20.
hero member
Activity: 556
Merit: 500
My hope is that because first impressions are critical, Bitmain will test the first batch for a few days (more than 24 hr), then select ONLY those machines that are flawless or close to it and send them out. If people will find trouble with the first batch, the whole program would be affected.
Hope in one hand, crap in the other, see what fills up first.
The reality is Bitmain released the U3 without any miner software (CGMiner) support. It was at least 2 weeks before initial buyers were able to use their U3s in any meaningful way. And that was ONLY because they were smart enough to give CK a unit and because he was kind enough to write drivers and update CGMiner.
legendary
Activity: 3892
Merit: 4331
My hope is that because first impressions are critical, Bitmain will test the first batch for a few days (more than 24 hr), then select ONLY those machines that are flawless or close to it and send them out. If people will find trouble with the first batch, the whole program would be affected.
legendary
Activity: 2338
Merit: 1124
You don't have to be in Ticino or any region close to the border to be cheaper than anybody else. The issue is to find the cheapest power possible.... Unfortunately, this doesn't work for miners coming from Israel for there you have to pay VAT in Switzerland, too.

Israeli miners I can host cheap in the US/China already with no VAT thank you very much. Smiley

My saying.
legendary
Activity: 3220
Merit: 1220
You don't have to be in Ticino or any region close to the border to be cheaper than anybody else. The issue is to find the cheapest power possible.... Unfortunately, this doesn't work for miners coming from Israel for there you have to pay VAT in Switzerland, too.

Ouch cheap shot!

I'd be all over cheap hosting in Switzerland if there was any or anything to host there Smiley

Don't get me wrong, I'd be all for it if it was really a possibility, I just think you are overestimating the cost/time savings for little return.

Israeli miners I can host cheap in the US/China already with no VAT thank you very much. Smiley
legendary
Activity: 2338
Merit: 1124

Beside this, many look at the situation in their country, not analysing the whole situation. Just a scenario: Switzerland and China have a free trade agreement. So no VAT or whatsoever is due for importing the miners to Switzerland. There, they can be stored without any problem in the duty free area. So they - technically - are still ex-Switzerland. For sending them around in Europe, you wouldn't have to invent the wheel: There are existing companies which do this. Easy and cheap. So if Bitmain would analyse how many miners they could sell in Europe, they could easily store them there before sales start and ship them very quickly around in Europe. If this would save Bitmain AND the clients a couple of bucks, it would be fine.
Furthermore, if you know where, you will be able to find very cheap electricity in Switzerland.... So European miners who would have to pay like 20% VAT could leave the miners in Switzerland for cheap mining - without paying ANY VAT.

With creativity and research, there would be a lot of possibilities to save money for both sides....

LOL Switzerland? The country with the most expensive workforce in mainland Europe?

Unless you're based out of Ticino and hire italians -- or -- partner with a hosting provider so people in the EU can buy units and get a cheaper power rate as well as avoiding VAT completely and easily.




You don't have to be in Ticino or any region close to the border to be cheaper than anybody else. The issue is to find the cheapest power possible.... Unfortunately, this doesn't work for miners coming from Israel for there you have to pay VAT in Switzerland, too.
hero member
Activity: 1118
Merit: 541

Beside this, many look at the situation in their country, not analysing the whole situation. Just a scenario: Switzerland and China have a free trade agreement. So no VAT or whatsoever is due for importing the miners to Switzerland. There, they can be stored without any problem in the duty free area. So they - technically - are still ex-Switzerland. For sending them around in Europe, you wouldn't have to invent the wheel: There are existing companies which do this. Easy and cheap. So if Bitmain would analyse how many miners they could sell in Europe, they could easily store them there before sales start and ship them very quickly around in Europe. If this would save Bitmain AND the clients a couple of bucks, it would be fine.
Furthermore, if you know where, you will be able to find very cheap electricity in Switzerland.... So European miners who would have to pay like 20% VAT could leave the miners in Switzerland for cheap mining - without paying ANY VAT.

With creativity and research, there would be a lot of possibilities to save money for both sides....

LOL Switzerland? The country with the most expensive workforce in mainland Europe?

Unless you're based out of Ticino and hire italians -- or -- partner with a hosting provider so people in the EU can buy units and get a cheaper power rate as well as avoiding VAT completely and easily.


legendary
Activity: 2338
Merit: 1124

Beside this, many look at the situation in their country, not analysing the whole situation. Just a scenario: Switzerland and China have a free trade agreement. So no VAT or whatsoever is due for importing the miners to Switzerland. There, they can be stored without any problem in the duty free area. So they - technically - are still ex-Switzerland. For sending them around in Europe, you wouldn't have to invent the wheel: There are existing companies which do this. Easy and cheap. So if Bitmain would analyse how many miners they could sell in Europe, they could easily store them there before sales start and ship them very quickly around in Europe. If this would save Bitmain AND the clients a couple of bucks, it would be fine.
Furthermore, if you know where, you will be able to find very cheap electricity in Switzerland.... So European miners who would have to pay like 20% VAT could leave the miners in Switzerland for cheap mining - without paying ANY VAT.

With creativity and research, there would be a lot of possibilities to save money for both sides....

LOL Switzerland? The country with the most expensive workforce in mainland Europe?

Yup.
legendary
Activity: 3220
Merit: 1220

Beside this, many look at the situation in their country, not analysing the whole situation. Just a scenario: Switzerland and China have a free trade agreement. So no VAT or whatsoever is due for importing the miners to Switzerland. There, they can be stored without any problem in the duty free area. So they - technically - are still ex-Switzerland. For sending them around in Europe, you wouldn't have to invent the wheel: There are existing companies which do this. Easy and cheap. So if Bitmain would analyse how many miners they could sell in Europe, they could easily store them there before sales start and ship them very quickly around in Europe. If this would save Bitmain AND the clients a couple of bucks, it would be fine.
Furthermore, if you know where, you will be able to find very cheap electricity in Switzerland.... So European miners who would have to pay like 20% VAT could leave the miners in Switzerland for cheap mining - without paying ANY VAT.

With creativity and research, there would be a lot of possibilities to save money for both sides....

LOL Switzerland? The country with the most expensive workforce in mainland Europe?
legendary
Activity: 2338
Merit: 1124
So distribution in EU from Switzerland would only encounter the extra warehousing cost from Switzerland.

Vat only becoming chargeable if they are exported to the EU.

So Bitmain or a third party could Host miners in Switzerland?



Sure they could. But they have their mining operations in China, so aren't interested in this.
hero member
Activity: 868
Merit: 1000
So distribution in EU from Switzerland would only encounter the extra warehousing cost from Switzerland.

Vat only becoming chargeable if they are exported to the EU.

So Bitmain or a third party could Host miners in Switzerland?

legendary
Activity: 2338
Merit: 1124
Loading up LD3 containers is always cheaper than UPS.  I am surprised Bitmain (or other suppliers) don't do this.  

By the way, I used to pay over $1,000,000 a year to UPS for shipping, so I know how low they can go.   UPS can never ship 100 shipment (with 100 customs clearances - the real hidden cost in all of this) cheaper than 1 air freight shipment with 1 customs clearance (with the same amount of goods as the 100 orders).  

Personally, I think BitMain just focuses on other things and hasn't put the energy into making this happen (which is fine if they have more pressing things).  However, if you can move weight, air freight then UPS (or whoever) to deliver in country will always be cheaper.  I havnt looked into prices lately, but our rate was about $900 for each LD3 moving 1/3 of the way around the globe.  This is for 1500 KG, so you are talking about $2.00 to ship a S5 across the world.  UPS will not move a S5 any distance for $2.00, let alone across the world.  

BitMain - I or someone else can make it happen, look into it!! Smiley

Hear that! At last, someone who knows what they are talking about!

What a fantastic x-mas present that is @dance191 ! You are a breath of fresh air in this stale environment jam-packed with people spouting their ignorance and passing it off as fact. @dogie and such like - EAT THAT!

Problem is the reasons listed a few posts back: it costs a lot of money and time to setup a warehouse in EU which will likely need 4-7 locals to staff it at minimum. Shipping from china is already available to them at a reasonable price and does not include the 12month contract risks and unknowns of a new office in a new country.

....
Always disappointing to hear such flimsy arguments ..... all I'll say is, if you do not have anything to say, do not say it.

Yeah, I did this for 10 years so I know how it all works.  Often people here say things like it is fact, when they are really just guessing.  Earlier, people were arguing with Mr Teal about what a PCI-E cable can do.   Little do they know he has his own line of miners he has designed, I think the man knows what he is talking about. 

Just like people can't wrap their head around 20,000 watts going through a PCI-E cable, they don't understand international logistics. 

Beside this, many look at the situation in their country, not analysing the whole situation. Just a scenario: Switzerland and China have a free trade agreement. So no VAT or whatsoever is due for importing the miners to Switzerland. There, they can be stored without any problem in the duty free area. So they - technically - are still ex-Switzerland. For sending them around in Europe, you wouldn't have to invent the wheel: There are existing companies which do this. Easy and cheap. So if Bitmain would analyse how many miners they could sell in Europe, they could easily store them there before sales start and ship them very quickly around in Europe. If this would save Bitmain AND the clients a couple of bucks, it would be fine.
Furthermore, if you know where, you will be able to find very cheap electricity in Switzerland.... So European miners who would have to pay like 20% VAT could leave the miners in Switzerland for cheap mining - without paying ANY VAT.

With creativity and research, there would be a lot of possibilities to save money for both sides....
Jump to: