Let's not derail from the main subject. Why are you favoring old and outdated ratings instead of adjusting them to reflect reality?
Read the changelog.
Topic: [Guide] Dogie's Comprehensive Manufacturer Trustworthiness Guide [1st Feb 2016] - page 15. (Read 131506 times)
January 27, 2015, 06:51:07 PM
Read the changelog.
January 27, 2015, 06:50:49 PM
When is the last sale made from bitfury to the general public?
About 6 weeks ago last I checkedSame question for Canann Creative ?
Permanently, longer than SP.
I may think it should be 92 sp-tech then 84 or 82 bitmaintech then 80 or 78 asicminer. then avalon for 76-78
You can't just make up total numbers, if you're going to suggest scores then do it on a category by category basis on each company.
I like dogie in general he has listed lots of gear over the years with different photos and good info so people trust his opinion. This thread is just a bit out of date for a home miner.
If you want a home miner's list then it wouldn't include SP.... their miners are specifically targeted for the industrial user, every single model has been astoundingly loud at stock and the majority of their trade is with industrial customers. So... we'd be left with CC and BM as the main people. Even AM design industrial miners now, which individual users can purchase.
January 27, 2015, 11:36:54 AM
Bitfury is 92
Canann Creative is 92
Spondoolies-Tech is 88
Bitmaintech is 86
When is the last sale made from bitfury to the general public?
Same question for Canann Creative ?
As for Sp tech at 88
And bitmaintech at 86
Sp tech has been better since Nov of last year.
If you want to argue about the list Dogie is listing Sp-tech over bitmaintech which is correct.
I may think it should be 92 sp-tech
then 84 or 82 bitmaintech
then 80 or 78 asicminer.
then avalon for 76-78
leave off all companies not selling currently to the home miner or make a
data center list vs a home miner list.
I may decide to do a home-miners guide to gear/asic companies geared to current sellers/builders for the home miner.
I like dogie in general he has listed lots of gear over the years with different photos and good info so people trust his opinion. This thread is just a bit out of date for a home miner.
+1Canann Creative is 92
Spondoolies-Tech is 88
Bitmaintech is 86
When is the last sale made from bitfury to the general public?
Same question for Canann Creative ?
As for Sp tech at 88
And bitmaintech at 86
Sp tech has been better since Nov of last year.
If you want to argue about the list Dogie is listing Sp-tech over bitmaintech which is correct.
I may think it should be 92 sp-tech
then 84 or 82 bitmaintech
then 80 or 78 asicminer.
then avalon for 76-78
leave off all companies not selling currently to the home miner or make a
data center list vs a home miner list.
I may decide to do a home-miners guide to gear/asic companies geared to current sellers/builders for the home miner.
I like dogie in general he has listed lots of gear over the years with different photos and good info so people trust his opinion. This thread is just a bit out of date for a home miner.
I don't see how the list help a consumer miner make an informed choice. For some reason Dogie decided to tweak the scoring.
He punishes us for taking pre-orders on the 2nd gen, which isn't relevant for the last 3 months.
January 27, 2015, 10:16:42 AM
Bitfury is 92
Canann Creative is 92
Spondoolies-Tech is 88
Bitmaintech is 86
When is the last sale made from bitfury to the general public?
Same question for Canann Creative ?
As for Sp tech at 88
And bitmaintech at 86
Sp tech has been better since Nov of last year.
If you want to argue about the list Dogie is listing Sp-tech over bitmaintech which is correct.
I may think it should be 92 sp-tech
then 84 or 82 bitmaintech
then 80 or 78 asicminer.
then avalon for 76-78
leave off all companies not selling currently to the home miner or make a
data center list vs a home miner list.
I may decide to do a home-miners guide to gear/asic companies geared to current sellers/builders for the home miner.
I like dogie in general he has listed lots of gear over the years with different photos and good info so people trust his opinion. This thread is just a bit out of date for a home miner.
Canann Creative is 92
Spondoolies-Tech is 88
Bitmaintech is 86
When is the last sale made from bitfury to the general public?
Same question for Canann Creative ?
As for Sp tech at 88
And bitmaintech at 86
Sp tech has been better since Nov of last year.
If you want to argue about the list Dogie is listing Sp-tech over bitmaintech which is correct.
I may think it should be 92 sp-tech
then 84 or 82 bitmaintech
then 80 or 78 asicminer.
then avalon for 76-78
leave off all companies not selling currently to the home miner or make a
data center list vs a home miner list.
I may decide to do a home-miners guide to gear/asic companies geared to current sellers/builders for the home miner.
I like dogie in general he has listed lots of gear over the years with different photos and good info so people trust his opinion. This thread is just a bit out of date for a home miner.
January 27, 2015, 09:54:35 AM
Let's not derail from the main subject. Why are you favoring old and outdated ratings instead of adjusting them to reflect reality?
January 27, 2015, 09:49:49 AM
so, explain the motive, dogie, oh ye of bitmaintech lapdoggie 
Bitmain have been about 10 points lower than they used to be since I started doing work from them, and are rank #4. Next idea.
The fact that your employer got their deserve ranking,
while their biggest competition ranking is skew-iff, does raise questions
SP ranking is skewed since you are a BMT employee, put 100 Sp-Tech.
Let me get this straight, you're saying that because I lowered the score of a company I've done work for, that I am biased on behalf of that company? By putting 3 other companies above them? Okay.
lowering it in the first place, aye.
January 27, 2015, 09:06:30 AM
so, explain the motive, dogie, oh ye of bitmaintech lapdoggie
Bitmain have been about 10 points lower than they used to be since I started doing work from them, and are rank #4. Next idea.
The fact that your employer got their deserve ranking,
while their biggest competition ranking is skew-iff, does raise questions
SP ranking is skewed since you are a BMT employee, put 100 Sp-Tech.
Let me get this straight, you're saying that because I lowered the score of a company I've done work for, that I am biased on behalf of that company? By putting 3 other companies above them? Okay.
lowering it in the first place, aye.
January 27, 2015, 08:59:59 AM
so, explain the motive, dogie, oh ye of bitmaintech lapdoggie
Bitmain have been about 10 points lower than they used to be since I started doing work from them, and are rank #4. Next idea.
The fact that your employer got their deserve ranking,
while their biggest competition ranking is skew-iff, does raise questions
SP ranking is skewed since you are a BMT employee, put 100 Sp-Tech.
Let me get this straight, you're saying that because I lowered the score of a company I've done work for, that I am biased on behalf of that company? By putting 3 other companies above them? Okay.
January 27, 2015, 08:57:30 AM
so, explain the motive, dogie, oh ye of bitmaintech lapdoggie
Bitmain have been about 10 points lower than they used to be since I started doing work from them, and are rank #4. Next idea.
The fact that your employer got their deserve ranking,
while their biggest competition ranking is skew-iff, does raise questions
SP ranking is skewed since you are a BMT employee, put 100 Sp-Tech.
January 27, 2015, 08:39:03 AM
so, explain the motive, dogie, oh ye of bitmaintech lapdoggie
Bitmain have been about 10 points lower than they used to be since I started doing work from them, and are rank #4. Next idea.
January 27, 2015, 08:33:47 AM
so, explain the motive, dogie, oh ye of bitmaintech lapdoggie
January 27, 2015, 08:09:49 AM
...
In general, I believe you're doing a decent job with the guide.- SpondooliesTech Preorders up from 'Yes' to 'Mix' (1 to 8]. *Although SpondooliesTech is currently selling out of hand, they have not yet demonstrated that their business model can support this into the next generation. On the announcement of next gen preorders, this rating will return to 'Yes'. On the announcement of next gen in hand / batch sales, this rating will increase to 'Batch' or 'No'.
Regarding our score, we're currently selling from stock all our products line. It seems to me a bit unfair and last minute change of your scoring criteria.
I strongly believe we should get 100 by your criteria. It seems that you avoid publishing an update or come up with new criteria like the above just to avoid what should be rightfully our score by your criteria.
Guy
And what motive would I have for that?
January 27, 2015, 07:58:16 AM
...
In general, I believe you're doing a decent job with the guide.- SpondooliesTech Preorders up from 'Yes' to 'Mix' (1 to 8]. *Although SpondooliesTech is currently selling out of hand, they have not yet demonstrated that their business model can support this into the next generation. On the announcement of next gen preorders, this rating will return to 'Yes'. On the announcement of next gen in hand / batch sales, this rating will increase to 'Batch' or 'No'.
Regarding our score, we're currently selling from stock all our products line. It seems to me a bit unfair and last minute change of your scoring criteria.
I strongly believe we should get 100 by your criteria. It seems that you avoid publishing an update or come up with new criteria like the above just to avoid what should be rightfully our score by your criteria.
Guy
And what motive would I have for that?
January 27, 2015, 07:41:14 AM
...
In general, I believe you're doing a decent job with the guide.- SpondooliesTech Preorders up from 'Yes' to 'Mix' (1 to 8]. *Although SpondooliesTech is currently selling out of hand, they have not yet demonstrated that their business model can support this into the next generation. On the announcement of next gen preorders, this rating will return to 'Yes'. On the announcement of next gen in hand / batch sales, this rating will increase to 'Batch' or 'No'.
Regarding our score, we're currently selling from stock all our products line. It seems to me a bit unfair and last minute change of your scoring criteria.
I strongly believe we should get 100 by your criteria. It seems that you avoid publishing an update or come up with new criteria like the above just to avoid what should be rightfully our score by your criteria.
Guy
December 23, 2014, 02:07:14 AM
Added score colorings to the first half of the list. Let me know if you like it or if it gives you eye aids. I'll revert or add to the rest of the list depending on feedback in a bit.
The colors are nice I say add it to all of them. Also I agree about SP...it is refreshing to see such a legit ASIC company these days!
yes, more colour!
this forum ain't half pretty enough, i'm so glad we have dogie
Thanks for the feedback.
Added colors to the rest of them.
December 20, 2014, 02:46:46 PM
Added score colorings to the first half of the list. Let me know if you like it or if it gives you eye aids. I'll revert or add to the rest of the list depending on feedback in a bit.
The colors are nice I say add it to all of them. Also I agree about SP...it is refreshing to see such a legit ASIC company these days!
yes, more colour!
this forum ain't half pretty enough, i'm so glad we have dogie
Thanks for the feedback.
Dogie is a Sparkle Doge
<3
December 20, 2014, 02:26:33 PM
Added score colorings to the first half of the list. Let me know if you like it or if it gives you eye aids. I'll revert or add to the rest of the list depending on feedback in a bit.
The colors are nice I say add it to all of them. Also I agree about SP...it is refreshing to see such a legit ASIC company these days!
yes, more colour!
this forum ain't half pretty enough, i'm so glad we have dogie
Thanks for the feedback.
Dogie is a Sparkle Doge
<3 December 20, 2014, 02:20:14 PM
Added score colorings to the first half of the list. Let me know if you like it or if it gives you eye aids. I'll revert or add to the rest of the list depending on feedback in a bit.
The colors are nice I say add it to all of them. Also I agree about SP...it is refreshing to see such a legit ASIC company these days!
yes, more colour!
this forum ain't half pretty enough, i'm so glad we have dogie
Thanks for the feedback.
December 20, 2014, 02:25:59 AM
Added score colorings to the first half of the list. Let me know if you like it or if it gives you eye aids. I'll revert or add to the rest of the list depending on feedback in a bit.
The colors are nice I say add it to all of them. Also I agree about SP...it is refreshing to see such a legit ASIC company these days!
yes, more colour!
this forum ain't half pretty enough, i'm so glad we have dogie
December 19, 2014, 10:28:19 PM
Added score colorings to the first half of the list. Let me know if you like it or if it gives you eye aids. I'll revert or add to the rest of the list depending on feedback in a bit.
The colors are nice I say add it to all of them. Also I agree about SP...it is refreshing to see such a legit ASIC company these days!
Jump to: