There is no missing link. That's a myth.
Neanderthal, Cro-Magnon, Homo floresiensis, Homo erectus, Homo ergaster, Homo habilis, Paranthropus boisei, Paranthropus aethiopicus, Australopithecus africanus, Australopithecus afarensis ....
How come all these 'species' of humans existed in different times if evolution isn't true?
Topic: Why I'm an atheist - page 22. (Read 89022 times)
The strongest a person can do against believing that the universe was made by God, is to believe that he doesn't know how it was made.
Machine universe proves a maker. Combining complexity, cause-and-effect, and entropy, proves the maker was intelligent like a God would have to be. The order in the universe, and the great size of it proves that the maker was at least acting as ONE.
There is no proof for a multi-billion year old universe. Fun story, though.
There is no proof for evolution in any way we can design it. Fun story, though.
Check this out for the proof that there is no evolution - https://globalwarming-arclein.blogspot.com/2019/11/9-scientific-facts-prove-theory-of.html.
Check this out for the proof that there is no Big Bang - http://www.pathlights.com/ce_encyclopedia/sci-ev/sci_vs_ev_2.htm.
I know. These articles are a bit extensive, and might be difficult for a false religion believer like you to absorb in one sitting. But you should be able to see from them, that there is at least a great big chunk of doubt about the fact of evolution and BB. What this means is that you have a evolution/BB religion going for yourself until you factually answer the points presented by the articles.
Machine universe proves a maker. Combining complexity, cause-and-effect, and entropy, proves the maker was intelligent like a God would have to be. The order in the universe, and the great size of it proves that the maker was at least acting as ONE.
There is no proof for a multi-billion year old universe. Fun story, though.
There is no proof for evolution in any way we can design it. Fun story, though.
Check this out for the proof that there is no evolution - https://globalwarming-arclein.blogspot.com/2019/11/9-scientific-facts-prove-theory-of.html.
Check this out for the proof that there is no Big Bang - http://www.pathlights.com/ce_encyclopedia/sci-ev/sci_vs_ev_2.htm.
I know. These articles are a bit extensive, and might be difficult for a false religion believer like you to absorb in one sitting. But you should be able to see from them, that there is at least a great big chunk of doubt about the fact of evolution and BB. What this means is that you have a evolution/BB religion going for yourself until you factually answer the points presented by the articles.
So we did not come from Neanderthals... There was no homo habilis and homo erectus and this god made us the way we are now. It's all a myth. All those skeletons found, the dna sequence that's very similar to the one of modern monkeys. God created Adam and Eve and they kept fucking their children until there was a whole town of them inbreds.
I'm not a religion believer of any kind. I don't believe in bedtime stories about some guy being born of a virgin, who had a husband, who believed her when she told him that god came down and put a child into her belly.
Not really:
https://arxiv.org/abs/1404.1207
https://medium.com/the-physics-arxiv-blog/a-mathematical-proof-that-the-universe-could-have-formed-spontaneously-from-nothing-ed7ed0f304a3
Except that the science you show in the links is circular science. It doesn't have anything scientific at its base.
Check this out for the proof that there is no evolution - https://globalwarming-arclein.blogspot.com/2019/11/9-scientific-facts-prove-theory-of.html.
Check this out for the proof that there is no Big Bang - http://www.pathlights.com/ce_encyclopedia/sci-ev/sci_vs_ev_2.htm.
God is the one who produces proof. The universe is the proof of His existence. If you won't believe the universe proof, you wouldn't believe a selfie or ATM card and PIN.
It works only if you believe that the universe was made by your god.
It all depends on the definition of a god.
Some facts to consider, even if we assume the universe was made by a god.
It was a 13 billion years ago and that being ceased to exist.
The universe was made by this being , but then evolved by itself, which doesn't make you his intentional creation. He created matter and billions of years later some part of this matter made your neanderthal ancestor. In such case should you really be praying to a god that probably doesn't even know he made you and doesn't care. Just like you don't care what bacteria will grow on the shit you flushed yesterday.
The strongest a person can do against believing that the universe was made by God, is to believe that he doesn't know how it was made.
Machine universe proves a maker. Combining complexity, cause-and-effect, and entropy, proves the maker was intelligent like a God would have to be. The order in the universe, and the great size of it proves that the maker was at least acting as ONE.
There is no proof for a multi-billion year old universe. Fun story, though.
There is no proof for evolution in any way we can design it. Fun story, though.
Check this out for the proof that there is no evolution - https://globalwarming-arclein.blogspot.com/2019/11/9-scientific-facts-prove-theory-of.html.
Check this out for the proof that there is no Big Bang - http://www.pathlights.com/ce_encyclopedia/sci-ev/sci_vs_ev_2.htm.
I know. These articles are a bit extensive, and might be difficult for a false religion believer like you to absorb in one sitting. But you should be able to see from them, that there is at least a great big chunk of doubt about the fact of evolution and BB. What this means is that you have a evolution/BB religion going for yourself until you factually answer the points presented by the articles.
Not really:
https://arxiv.org/abs/1404.1207
https://medium.com/the-physics-arxiv-blog/a-mathematical-proof-that-the-universe-could-have-formed-spontaneously-from-nothing-ed7ed0f304a3
God is the one who produces proof. The universe is the proof of His existence. If you won't believe the universe proof, you wouldn't believe a selfie or ATM card and PIN.
It works only if you believe that the universe was made by your god.
It all depends on the definition of a god.
Some facts to consider, even if we assume the universe was made by a god.
It was a 13 billion years ago and that being ceased to exist.
The universe was made by this being , but then evolved by itself, which doesn't make you his intentional creation. He created matter and billions of years later some part of this matter made your neanderthal ancestor. In such case should you really be praying to a god that probably doesn't even know he made you and doesn't care. Just like you don't care what bacteria will grow on the shit you flushed yesterday.
The strongest a person can do against believing that the universe was made by God, is to believe that he doesn't know how it was made.
Machine universe proves a maker. Combining complexity, cause-and-effect, and entropy, proves the maker was intelligent like a God would have to be. The order in the universe, and the great size of it proves that the maker was at least acting as ONE.
There is no proof for a multi-billion year old universe. Fun story, though.
There is no proof for evolution in any way we can design it. Fun story, though.
Check this out for the proof that there is no evolution - https://globalwarming-arclein.blogspot.com/2019/11/9-scientific-facts-prove-theory-of.html.
Check this out for the proof that there is no Big Bang - http://www.pathlights.com/ce_encyclopedia/sci-ev/sci_vs_ev_2.htm.
I know. These articles are a bit extensive, and might be difficult for a false religion believer like you to absorb in one sitting. But you should be able to see from them, that there is at least a great big chunk of doubt about the fact of evolution and BB. What this means is that you have a evolution/BB religion going for yourself until you factually answer the points presented by the articles.
I have told you many times, I would accept any proof you can provide.
A selfie with God and a card that says: "BADecker" would do.
A post from God in this thread would be acceptable as well (please include my ATM card PIN number)
God is the one who produces proof. The universe is the proof of His existence. If you won't believe the universe proof, you wouldn't believe a selfie or ATM card and PIN.
Oh, I would.
BTW, the universe is not proof of God's existence unless you equate God with the universe.
But, if you do, you can safely lose the extra verbiage and call it by its proper name: the universe.
C'mon, it is just a number. Provide my PIN number and we can settle this right now. LOL.
Anyway, kidding aside, you should probably read this book:
https://www.amazon.com/Brave-New-World-Revisited/dp/0060776099/
It will put things into perspective for you. Maybe it will make you think for once.
God is the one who produces proof. The universe is the proof of His existence. If you won't believe the universe proof, you wouldn't believe a selfie or ATM card and PIN.
It works only if you believe that the universe was made by your god.
It all depends on the definition of a god.
Some facts to consider, even if we assume the universe was made by a god.
It was a 13 billion years ago and that being ceased to exist.
The universe was made by this being , but then evolved by itself, which doesn't make you his intentional creation. He created matter and billions of years later some part of this matter made your neanderthal ancestor. In such case should you really be praying to a god that probably doesn't even know he made you and doesn't care. Just like you don't care what bacteria will grow on the shit you flushed yesterday.
I have told you many times, I would accept any proof you can provide.
A selfie with God and a card that says: "BADecker" would do.
A post from God in this thread would be acceptable as well (please include my ATM card PIN number)
God is the one who produces proof. The universe is the proof of His existence. If you won't believe the universe proof, you wouldn't believe a selfie or ATM card and PIN.
If you are so vehemently against killing babies why are you accepting the Bible as your moral guide? You are obviously better than your God when it comes to the issue of killing babies.
Why do you think your God in the Bible is such a primitive, ignorant asshole?
I'll tell you why. Because he lived somewhere around 800-2500 BC and did not know better.
This book that you so cherish as divine is a product of human imagination.
Poorly written ancient tragic soap opera, not worth the paper it is written on.
https://www.christianpost.com/news/moloch-statue-child-sacrifice-colosseum-holy-site-christian-martyrs-233812
As I told you, sometimes it takes killing off the killers.
"Holy men of God spoke as they were moved by the Holy spirit"
Just because some Christians are bad at times, doesn't mean that God is ever bad.
In your lack of recognizing that God exists, you are setting yourself up for destruction. Since you personally aren't doing a lot of destruction, God might spare you for a long time, with the hope that you will recognize Him. But if you don't, your destruction is your choice.
We already have a medical term for this condition, it is called schizophrenia.
When you don't accept the proof that God exists and does what He pleases, it's essentially self-denial.
I have told you many times, I would accept any proof you can provide.
A selfie with God and a card that says: "BADecker" would do.
A post from God in this thread would be acceptable as well (please include my ATM card PIN number)
If you are so vehemently against killing babies why are you accepting the Bible as your moral guide? You are obviously better than your God when it comes to the issue of killing babies.
Why do you think your God in the Bible is such a primitive, ignorant asshole?
I'll tell you why. Because he lived somewhere around 800-2500 BC and did not know better.
This book that you so cherish as divine is a product of human imagination.
Poorly written ancient tragic soap opera, not worth the paper it is written on.
https://www.christianpost.com/news/moloch-statue-child-sacrifice-colosseum-holy-site-christian-martyrs-233812
As I told you, sometimes it takes killing off the killers.
"Holy men of God spoke as they were moved by the Holy spirit"
Just because some Christians are bad at times, doesn't mean that God is ever bad.
In your lack of recognizing that God exists, you are setting yourself up for destruction. Since you personally aren't doing a lot of destruction, God might spare you for a long time, with the hope that you will recognize Him. But if you don't, your destruction is your choice.
We already have a medical term for this condition, it is called schizophrenia.
When you don't accept the proof that God exists and does what He pleases, it's essentially self-denial.
A new study concluded that the Catholic Church converted Europeans on a more emphatic people able to trust strangers, by prohibiting marriage between close related family members, forcing people to deal with members of other communities more often.
"The policies of the medieval Catholic clergy may be responsible for modern psychology in the West."
https://www.livescience.com/catholic-church-made-westerners-weird.html
They argued that this promoted trade, exchange of ideas and so development. And also reinforced national community ties and democracy.
A sociological positive consequence of a religion? This would be something new.
However, their other conclusion that this also made Europeans more individualistic and independent of the family and local community is at odds with the classic conclusions of Max Weber, that Catholic doctrines created a more subservient and passive mentality in front of Protestantism that explained the decadence of the catholic countries and the higher development of protestant countries.
But other specialists argue that it wasn't the difference of mentalities that explained the decadence of catholic countries, but the incentive that protestant countries created for learning to read (in order to be able to read sacred texts, like in Judaism).
"The policies of the medieval Catholic clergy may be responsible for modern psychology in the West."
https://www.livescience.com/catholic-church-made-westerners-weird.html
They argued that this promoted trade, exchange of ideas and so development. And also reinforced national community ties and democracy.
A sociological positive consequence of a religion? This would be something new.
However, their other conclusion that this also made Europeans more individualistic and independent of the family and local community is at odds with the classic conclusions of Max Weber, that Catholic doctrines created a more subservient and passive mentality in front of Protestantism that explained the decadence of the catholic countries and the higher development of protestant countries.
But other specialists argue that it wasn't the difference of mentalities that explained the decadence of catholic countries, but the incentive that protestant countries created for learning to read (in order to be able to read sacred texts, like in Judaism).
If you are so vehemently against killing babies why are you accepting the Bible as your moral guide? You are obviously better than your God when it comes to the issue of killing babies.
Why do you think your God in the Bible is such a primitive, ignorant asshole?
I'll tell you why. Because he lived somewhere around 800-2500 BC and did not know better.
This book that you so cherish as divine is a product of human imagination.
Poorly written ancient tragic soap opera, not worth the paper it is written on.
https://www.christianpost.com/news/moloch-statue-child-sacrifice-colosseum-holy-site-christian-martyrs-233812
As I told you, sometimes it takes killing off the killers.
"Holy men of God spoke as they were moved by the Holy spirit"
Just because some Christians are bad at times, doesn't mean that God is ever bad.
In your lack of recognizing that God exists, you are setting yourself up for destruction. Since you personally aren't doing a lot of destruction, God might spare you for a long time, with the hope that you will recognize Him. But if you don't, your destruction is your choice.
We already have a medical term for this condition, it is called schizophrenia.
If you are so vehemently against killing babies why are you accepting the Bible as your moral guide? You are obviously better than your God when it comes to the issue of killing babies.
Why do you think your God in the Bible is such a primitive, ignorant asshole?
I'll tell you why. Because he lived somewhere around 800-2500 BC and did not know better.
This book that you so cherish as divine is a product of human imagination.
Poorly written ancient tragic soap opera, not worth the paper it is written on.
https://www.christianpost.com/news/moloch-statue-child-sacrifice-colosseum-holy-site-christian-martyrs-233812
As I told you, sometimes it takes killing off the killers.
"Holy men of God spoke as they were moved by the Holy spirit"
Just because some Christians are bad at times, doesn't mean that God is ever bad.
In your lack of recognizing that God exists, you are setting yourself up for destruction. Since you personally aren't doing a lot of destruction, God might spare you for a long time, with the hope that you will recognize Him. But if you don't, your destruction is your choice.
We already have a medical term for this condition, it is called schizophrenia.
If you are so vehemently against killing babies why are you accepting the Bible as your moral guide? You are obviously better than your God when it comes to the issue of killing babies.
Why do you think your God in the Bible is such a primitive, ignorant asshole?
I'll tell you why. Because he lived somewhere around 800-2500 BC and did not know better.
This book that you so cherish as divine is a product of human imagination.
Poorly written ancient tragic soap opera, not worth the paper it is written on.
https://www.christianpost.com/news/moloch-statue-child-sacrifice-colosseum-holy-site-christian-martyrs-233812
As I told you, sometimes it takes killing off the killers.
"Holy men of God spoke as they were moved by the Holy spirit"
Just because some Christians are bad at times, doesn't mean that God is ever bad.
In your lack of recognizing that God exists, you are setting yourself up for destruction. Since you personally aren't doing a lot of destruction, God might spare you for a long time, with the hope that you will recognize Him. But if you don't, your destruction is your choice.
I don't discard the idea of a God. There can be a creator for real, someone who is more intelligent than us, someone who's actually the creator of anything that exists today.
But, if he's that intelligent, I guess he will not be that boring to just tell to his creation "believe in me or I'll toast your ass in fire for eternity".
If he exists though, he's the one who's getting punished for eternity. He's lone. He's in solitude. If he is unlike anything of his creation, he doesn't have anything to compare to.
Yeah, he may say, how he knows everything. But what if he doesn't know something which he doesn't know?
Shouldn't that worry him? He's existing eternally with an eternal memory? Why doesn't he think how and why he's even there in the first place? Oh, he doesn't have a first place, shouldn't that make him worried? And lonely?
No one can really feel what he's feeling. No one can because he himself says it.
That's some real solitude to live in. Basically he can't even cease to exist. He doesn't even have a choice.
But, if he's that intelligent, I guess he will not be that boring to just tell to his creation "believe in me or I'll toast your ass in fire for eternity".
If he exists though, he's the one who's getting punished for eternity. He's lone. He's in solitude. If he is unlike anything of his creation, he doesn't have anything to compare to.
Yeah, he may say, how he knows everything. But what if he doesn't know something which he doesn't know?
Shouldn't that worry him? He's existing eternally with an eternal memory? Why doesn't he think how and why he's even there in the first place? Oh, he doesn't have a first place, shouldn't that make him worried? And lonely?
No one can really feel what he's feeling. No one can because he himself says it.
That's some real solitude to live in. Basically he can't even cease to exist. He doesn't even have a choice.
Spirit, soul - now you are talking nonsense again. There are no spirits or souls of any kind, anywhere!!! Grow up. - So said by God allowing the decision of your free-will soul.
If free will exists in your soul, does your soul exist in our deterministic world? Yes or no, please.
If yes, it is not free will because it must obey the deterministic laws of our deterministic universe.
If not, it cannot be the cause of anything in our deterministic universe. - In the universe, but not of the universe.
BTW, the same goes for your God object/concept, if it exists outside of our deterministic universe, it cannot be a cause of anything in this universe. If that is true, then there is no difference between your God object and any other object that does not exist. Lack of evidence supports that notion. - Outside of the universe, and inside of the universe, but not of the universe, except in the physical part of Jesus.
For the record, I am not convinced that our universe is deterministic. If you look at the quantum effects, it becomes abundantly clear that it is not. But please do not claim that God/souls/angels are the cause of non-deterministic quantum effects, because that would be another Christian heresy. - Nobody has proven quantum effect in nature without mankind making it... C&E.
BTW, the C&E regression can run ad infinitum. I see no logical argument that it cannot. Actually, it would be illogical to assume that it (God) started without a cause. However, the way our universe actually started, it is actually nonsensical to talk about a cause or effect in the absence of space-time. You need time to determine what is the cause and what is the effect. - You can't describe the qualities and attributes of God outside of the universe. What is C&E to us might be something completely different to God. But when God makes the universe, it becomes C&E to us.
As for our brain, it is an automaton; it responds to the environment, our actions are predicated on all the prior stimuli our brain received.
There is no independent free will, IMHO. There is an illusion of free will, but our actions, our thoughts are driven by what we have experienced in the past. Even when you make that final, split-second decision, it is made because of some last cause and the 100B neural network that processed that cause. - Another way to say what I have been stating all along. This means that there is no free will except if it is found outside the brain. "Outside the brain" can mean seeming to be within the brain, but outside of it "dimensionally."
PS. To answer your question. I do not believe in God because I have read all three Abrahamic holy books. It is clear that they were written by people to control other people. Writers projected their own personalities to the God they have created. It is fiction, a scientific nonsense. Moral rules listed in them are abhorrent. God is a psychologically comforting concept, but it has nothing to do with reality.
You talk about the Bible killing babies. But our abortions in the US have murdered way more babies than any holy book could ever think of killing. And our abortion clinics certainly aren't religious places in the sense of formal religions.
You might be a wonderful guy, yourself. But holy books are designed to get rid of the murders, even if it takes killing the murderers to stop the murders.
If you look in Ezekiel 18, you will see that God isn't interested in killing people. He is interested in getting rid of the killing. If the murderers stop murdering, God is ready to forgive and forget their past murders. And the same with their other evils.
If you are so vehemently against killing babies why are you accepting the Bible as your moral guide? You are obviously better than your God when it comes to the issue of killing babies.
Why do you think your God in the Bible is such a primitive, ignorant asshole?
I'll tell you why. Because he lived somewhere around 800-2500 BC and did not know better.
This book that you so cherish as divine is a product of human imagination.
Poorly written ancient tragic soap opera, not worth the paper it is written on.
https://www.christianpost.com/news/moloch-statue-child-sacrifice-colosseum-holy-site-christian-martyrs-233812
Spirit, soul - now you are talking nonsense again. There are no spirits or souls of any kind, anywhere!!! Grow up. - So said by God allowing the decision of your free-will soul.
If free will exists in your soul, does your soul exist in our deterministic world? Yes or no, please.
If yes, it is not free will because it must obey the deterministic laws of our deterministic universe.
If not, it cannot be the cause of anything in our deterministic universe. - In the universe, but not of the universe.
BTW, the same goes for your God object/concept, if it exists outside of our deterministic universe, it cannot be a cause of anything in this universe. If that is true, then there is no difference between your God object and any other object that does not exist. Lack of evidence supports that notion. - Outside of the universe, and inside of the universe, but not of the universe, except in the physical part of Jesus.
For the record, I am not convinced that our universe is deterministic. If you look at the quantum effects, it becomes abundantly clear that it is not. But please do not claim that God/souls/angels are the cause of non-deterministic quantum effects, because that would be another Christian heresy. - Nobody has proven quantum effect in nature without mankind making it... C&E.
BTW, the C&E regression can run ad infinitum. I see no logical argument that it cannot. Actually, it would be illogical to assume that it (God) started without a cause. However, the way our universe actually started, it is actually nonsensical to talk about a cause or effect in the absence of space-time. You need time to determine what is the cause and what is the effect. - You can't describe the qualities and attributes of God outside of the universe. What is C&E to us might be something completely different to God. But when God makes the universe, it becomes C&E to us.
As for our brain, it is an automaton; it responds to the environment, our actions are predicated on all the prior stimuli our brain received.
There is no independent free will, IMHO. There is an illusion of free will, but our actions, our thoughts are driven by what we have experienced in the past. Even when you make that final, split-second decision, it is made because of some last cause and the 100B neural network that processed that cause. - Another way to say what I have been stating all along. This means that there is no free will except if it is found outside the brain. "Outside the brain" can mean seeming to be within the brain, but outside of it "dimensionally."
PS. To answer your question. I do not believe in God because I have read all three Abrahamic holy books. It is clear that they were written by people to control other people. Writers projected their own personalities to the God they have created. It is fiction, a scientific nonsense. Moral rules listed in them are abhorrent. God is a psychologically comforting concept, but it has nothing to do with reality.
You talk about the Bible killing babies. But our abortions in the US have murdered way more babies than any holy book could ever think of killing. And our abortion clinics certainly aren't religious places in the sense of formal religions.
You might be a wonderful guy, yourself. But holy books are designed to get rid of the murders, even if it takes killing the murderers to stop the murders.
If you look in Ezekiel 18, you will see that God isn't interested in killing people. He is interested in getting rid of the killing. If the murderers stop murdering, God is ready to forgive and forget their past murders. And the same with their other evils.
"There are no spirits or souls"
You simply don't understand that your free will actions are dictated by the present bio-chemical situation of your synapses. And the present bio-chemical situation of your synapses is dictated by the food you ate, the water you drank, the radiant energy hitting your body, and all kinds of other firing synapses that might not have anything to do with your free will activity in question. So, it isn't really free will, since all these other activities are directing how it works.
What this all means is that your free will is situated somewhere else.
So you are a Christian heretic by denying that humans have free will.
Now we are getting warmer. There is no free will as defined by religious myths. That was my fucking point from the beginning. I was trying to explain the Christian dogma to you because you do not understand what it says and what it means.
Now, that you understand that there is no free will we can both agree that God is responsible (cause) for all the evil in this world. Again. I am just stating what your religious dogma says. I do not believe in evil or God. Just bad/good shit happens to good/bad people.
As for randomness, it is observable, read the PDF I posted, it seems like it is an emergent property of the underlying system. Check the causal fermion system theory.
BTW, I do not believe in ANY details from any religious myths. Free will, demons, angels, sin, God, hell or heaven. It is all made up shit to scare people and give the religious conmen 10% of their income. Gypsies lifting curses, card readers, fortune tellers, religious preachers are all the same, conmen.
As usual you missed something. This time it is the fact that I said we have free will.
The fact that you don't believe what God says, shows that you believe in the myth that God doesn't exist. Rather religious of you.
I did not miss it. You say a lot of nonsense, to reply to all of it just takes too much of my time.
Your statement is even more irrational than your religious myth.
The free will that we supposedly possess is not in this world, but somehow we can still use it to affect our deterministic world in non-deterministic (free will) fashion. Do you hear yourself?
You just shift things around to cling to your mythology. "God is outside of the known universe, space-time that is why we cannot detect him, yet he controls everything in this universe; now, the free will is somewhere else outside of our deterministic world, etc."
As science discovers more and more and invalidates every single detail in the Bible, you have to move the goalposts, change the meaning of words, reinterpret the verses, and redefine what and where God and free will are.
You are making shit up as you go.
You have no logical arguments, other than entropy increases, therefore we had low entropy when the universe started, therefore God started the universe. Yet, when scientists make similar extrapolation about the space-time and conclude that the universe started with a BB, you object.
When I showed you that you cannot have free will in the deterministic universe, you claim that the free will exist but it is not in this universe.
You make no sense. When I say A is dependent on B, you say A is not dependent on B because B is not B.
That is the crux of all of your arguments.
Notice that you won't even accept soul and spirit, and that is where the actual free will of people exists. The brain is subject to deterministic activity. So, free will doesn't exist there.
Since you won't accept soul and spirit, they certainly don't exist in this world. At least not according to you.
Since the machine nature of the universe exists all around us, especially in determinism, God exists. Machines have makers.
So, why do you continue to remain in the attitude that God doesn't exist? Further, it's not a surprise that you think that I make stuff up about free will. You don't even recognize the free will that you have, the free will that God exercises for you because you are too weak to use it yourself, and are too weak to even recognize that it exists. Or do you agree free will exists, and yet not agree that the brain acts by determinism? If that is the way you think, then where is your free will?
Spirit, soul - now you are talking nonsense again. There are no spirits or souls of any kind, anywhere!!! Grow up.
If free will exists in your soul, does your soul exist in our deterministic world? Yes or no, please.
If yes, it is not free will because it must obey the deterministic laws of our deterministic universe.
If not, it cannot be the cause of anything in our deterministic universe.
BTW, the same goes for your God object/concept, if it exists outside of our deterministic universe, it cannot be a cause of anything in this universe. If that is true, then there is no difference between your God object and any other object that does not exist. Lack of evidence supports that notion.
For the record, I am not convinced that our universe is deterministic. If you look at the quantum effects, it becomes abundantly clear that it is not. But please do not claim that God/souls/angels are the cause of non-deterministic quantum effects, because that would be another Christian heresy.
BTW, the C&E regression can run ad infinitum. I see no logical argument that it cannot. Actually, it would be illogical to assume that it (God) started without a cause. However, the way our universe actually started, it is actually nonsensical to talk about a cause or effect in the absence of space-time. You need time to determine what is the cause and what is the effect.
As for our brain, it is an automaton; it responds to the environment, our actions are predicated on all the prior stimuli our brain received.
There is no independent free will, IMHO. There is an illusion of free will, but our actions, our thoughts are driven by what we have experienced in the past. Even when you make that final, split-second decision, it is made because of some last cause and the 100B neural network that processed that cause.
PS. To answer your question. I do not believe in God because I have read all three Abrahamic holy books. It is clear that they were written by people to control other people. Writers projected their own personalities to the God they have created. It is fiction, a scientific nonsense. Moral rules listed in them are abhorrent. God is a psychologically comforting concept, but it has nothing to do with reality.
You simply don't understand that your free will actions are dictated by the present bio-chemical situation of your synapses. And the present bio-chemical situation of your synapses is dictated by the food you ate, the water you drank, the radiant energy hitting your body, and all kinds of other firing synapses that might not have anything to do with your free will activity in question. So, it isn't really free will, since all these other activities are directing how it works.
What this all means is that your free will is situated somewhere else.
So you are a Christian heretic by denying that humans have free will.
Now we are getting warmer. There is no free will as defined by religious myths. That was my fucking point from the beginning. I was trying to explain the Christian dogma to you because you do not understand what it says and what it means.
Now, that you understand that there is no free will we can both agree that God is responsible (cause) for all the evil in this world. Again. I am just stating what your religious dogma says. I do not believe in evil or God. Just bad/good shit happens to good/bad people.
As for randomness, it is observable, read the PDF I posted, it seems like it is an emergent property of the underlying system. Check the causal fermion system theory.
BTW, I do not believe in ANY details from any religious myths. Free will, demons, angels, sin, God, hell or heaven. It is all made up shit to scare people and give the religious conmen 10% of their income. Gypsies lifting curses, card readers, fortune tellers, religious preachers are all the same, conmen.
As usual you missed something. This time it is the fact that I said we have free will.
The fact that you don't believe what God says, shows that you believe in the myth that God doesn't exist. Rather religious of you.
I did not miss it. You say a lot of nonsense, to reply to all of it just takes too much of my time.
Your statement is even more irrational than your religious myth.
The free will that we supposedly possess is not in this world, but somehow we can still use it to affect our deterministic world in non-deterministic (free will) fashion. Do you hear yourself?
You just shift things around to cling to your mythology. "God is outside of the known universe, space-time that is why we cannot detect him, yet he controls everything in this universe; now, the free will is somewhere else outside of our deterministic world, etc."
As science discovers more and more and invalidates every single detail in the Bible, you have to move the goalposts, change the meaning of words, reinterpret the verses, and redefine what and where God and free will are.
You are making shit up as you go.
You have no logical arguments, other than entropy increases, therefore we had low entropy when the universe started, therefore God started the universe. Yet, when scientists make similar extrapolation about the space-time and conclude that the universe started with a BB, you object.
When I showed you that you cannot have free will in the deterministic universe, you claim that the free will exist but it is not in this universe.
You make no sense. When I say A is dependent on B, you say A is not dependent on B because B is not B.
That is the crux of all of your arguments.
Notice that you won't even accept soul and spirit, and that is where the actual free will of people exists. The brain is subject to deterministic activity. So, free will doesn't exist there.
Since you won't accept soul and spirit, they certainly don't exist in this world. At least not according to you.
Since the machine nature of the universe exists all around us, especially in determinism, God exists. Machines have makers.
So, why do you continue to remain in the attitude that God doesn't exist? Further, it's not a surprise that you think that I make stuff up about free will. You don't even recognize the free will that you have, the free will that God exercises for you because you are too weak to use it yourself, and are too weak to even recognize that it exists. Or do you agree free will exists, and yet not agree that the brain acts by determinism? If that is the way you think, then where is your free will?
Jump to: