if I do not feel able to kill my own child even though the god who told him, because the child is the most valuable god, is not God more able to take his life than his parents ... !!!
Topic: Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to? - page 4. (Read 9690 times)
if I do not feel able to kill my own child even though the god who told him, because the child is the most valuable god, is not God more able to take his life than his parents ... !!!
No, and I would go to the nearest doctor if I heard a voice in my head telling me to.
I would send God to hell! After all, these are my children and I have to protect them from death.
I would never kill my children just because God told me so. If I do that, maybe I'm already mentally ill and I could go to prison for parricide. I love my baby so much, and I dont think I can do it with my right mind.
No ofcourse not i would not kill my own childred even god command it because god never command you to do anything bad to you and other people
There is no god out there, so he can't command you about anything. But obviously I have heard about serial killers claiming that god asked them to kill people and that is why they made all those murders. IMO, it is just an excuse to justify their crimes and an attempt to put the blame on someone else.
Well, apparently if God asks you to do anything, you have to do it. There are a few example of child sacrifice in the bible, the most known being the story of Abraham and Isaac. But that story didn't result in Isaac dying because God was only testing Abraham.
No ofcourse not i would not kill my own childred even god command it because god never command you to do anything bad to you and other people
No, absolutly not! A god who wants to make me do that isn't different then a demon and therefore not worth to be trusted in
Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to?
A perfectly valid legit question.
Please no attempts to derail the thread with nonsense like "God would never say that" or "God would never change the rules with murder" etc....
behind the injunctions that hurt us there must be a wisdom in it. because god is omniscient and omniscient. if he orders to kill my own child, I will ask my wife and my son for the message that God gives to me. if my child approves it I will do it, but if my child does not approve it I will pray and ask for directions to him. what should I do to my child so that I have greater confidence and trust to do so. A perfectly valid legit question.
Please no attempts to derail the thread with nonsense like "God would never say that" or "God would never change the rules with murder" etc....
So really, I see two options here. If my child is sent to Hell, there is absolutely no way I'm killing my child. I'd much prefer myself to suffer eternal damnation than my child. But if I was guaranteed that my child would go to Heaven in death, that would make things more sticky. I mean, sure it's still a horrible thing to do, but my child and I both getting into Heaven certainly sounds like the best case scenario here in the long run, compared to me refusing to kill him and automatically going to Hell and my child being a theoretical coinflip on where they go upon death.
Yes I would do any thing that god orders me to do. It is because that god plans the whole scenario of my life. So if god recommends me to do any thing he will have the future planned for me. so I'm not afraid of doing what god requires from me to do.
Something tells me you'll be in a courtroom someday charged with murder cause voices in your head told you to kill.... :/
no because its prophetic gods command purposes only even its prohecied was also fulfilled so knowing god not request of this anyone ever
do it gain constanly harm or kill your own child?,is not a luck of faith but rather right understanding of god such a message or command sometimes could only came from evil and deceptive spirit only ,,don't let atheist silly and unfounded question trip you up more often than not they are arguing from luck of understanding or like in this case based on fact while ignoring the rest,
do it gain constanly harm or kill your own child?,is not a luck of faith but rather right understanding of god such a message or command sometimes could only came from evil and deceptive spirit only ,,don't let atheist silly and unfounded question trip you up more often than not they are arguing from luck of understanding or like in this case based on fact while ignoring the rest,
I don't know because reality is big different from story or theory. It is very hard to kill your own son and very hard also to disobeyed.
It is deeply disturbing that 25% of people would kill their own children for the invisible sky daddy. Deeply disturbing indeed.
I honestly believe that organized religion is some sort of mental infection, that manages to spread from person to person, poisoning their mind.
I honestly believe that organized religion is some sort of mental infection, that manages to spread from person to person, poisoning their mind.
No. I believe at that point my understanding of Islam would prove to be completely void. However, reaching a level of enlightenment that allows me to have an actual conversation with God would mean I'm already dead.
If God commands me to kill my children, if i can kill the god, i will if not i will just walk away from him.
i better be a Muslim than kill my children!
why dont god tell all human to kill those criminals especially rapist! why can't he kill those priests who are the sinner?
i better be a Muslim than kill my children!
why dont god tell all human to kill those criminals especially rapist! why can't he kill those priests who are the sinner?
No way,I won't do that.If this god ask me to kill my children he will confirm that he's a sadistic god or whatever he is.
So,for me he doesn't deserve my obedience .
So,for me he doesn't deserve my obedience .
Would you kill your own children if God commanded you to?
A perfectly valid legit question.
Please no attempts to derail the thread with nonsense like "God would never say that" or "God would never change the rules with murder" etc....
For me i will just like abraham do to isaac he sacrifice his only son just to obey gods command but inside of me i cant but for gods command i will do even if its my own child yeah maybe it hurts when your child is gone but you should obey because everything happens for a reason and there a gods plan for you . A perfectly valid legit question.
Please no attempts to derail the thread with nonsense like "God would never say that" or "God would never change the rules with murder" etc....
No, never. Wouldn't want to obey a God that issued such demands. Besides, I'd be so scared that I was actually tripping, hallucinating, or dreaming, rather than hearing the word of God, and would never kill anyone over what a disembodied voice told me in such conditions.
No i rather not. I will protect my children at all cost. He must kill his child first.
I would send God to hell! After all, these are my children and I have to protect them from death.
If so -called god commands me to kill my own child, I will do same thing with you. Human beings must protect their own child from any horrible situation. Even if creator of this horrible situation is God.
Jump to: