Hi everyone,
I have not been on this thread/coin for a while and I was surprised to find that there is no official/endorsed GUI wallet.
I like this coin but it is never going to go main stream unless those rough edges are polished.
I understand the community has created two GUI's so just take a version, endorse and host on a Monero site.
Wording like 'All current GUIs are in beta, but they should be fairly safe ' does not fill people with confidence.
Also how often is the block chain on the OP being updated ?
An ambitious official GUI is under development, but there are other things that need to be tackled before being able to release a proper GUI wallet for the masses. One of those things is the blockchain in DB format instead of loading it entirely into RAM (this was inherited from the original bytecoin code). The BlockchainDB version has been evolving and you can try it out on your own if you are capable of building it on Linux, but it still needs some work and a lot of testing.
IMO, It's not about embracing one of the currently available GUIs. People can use and develop whichever GUI they want, that's the nature of open source software. Core members have their own view of what a GUI wallet should be like, and they are aiming for that. They have shown designs and have released a preview version of it.
Good software development requires solid design, capable coders and a lot of time. Core members work for free on their free time, but they are also humans (I think) and they also have a life (I think
).
I would also love for development to go faster, but wishing and pushing for it won't make it happen any sooner.
Hopefully we will see a GUI sooner than later. Some have rumored about it being released around Christmas, but I don't expect that to be true. Core members have not made any promise about it, and won't make any promise they can't keep (except for missives on Mondays... just kidding
)
All I take as a fact, is that it will be done "when it's done"
tm.
Having said that... I do believe in the potential of this coin and I have faith in the team behind it.
Thanks for the detailed answer and I can understand why you want to load the blockchain into a database. The blockchain is starting to get big! I am curious as a IT bod how you are going to index the blockchain as penultimately this is what you have to do. Does it already contain a multi level index or do you need to add some extra information over the blockchain? Good luck ;-) Personally I think long term that blockchain will be held centrally as they will get too big then you just connect to a service for proving personal coins. Have you thought about skipping the interim database approach and implementing a centralised or even distributed block chain ? I am guessing the later options would take too much effort / money....