Provide your estimates then, since I can't see a mistake in mine.
I have exact calculations I'd rather not post but I'll do a back of an envelope here.
BCN block reward in coins is about 6400 times the XMR reward. The value of XMR is about 40000 times BCN. Combined these make the BCN reward worth about 16% of the XMR reward. The difficulty of XMR is about 10.5 times the difficulty of BCN. So by these numbers if you do 1/10.5 as much work you can get about 1/6 of the reward. Better to mine BCN.
This ignores other second order factors such as orphan rate, etc.
Ok, my estimates are (leaving out orphans, block penatlies, etc.):
Daily emission (from minergate.com and monerochain.info):
BCN: 79,200,000
XMR: 23,000
Difficulty (from Bytecoin.org and monerochain.info):
BCN: 103,000,000
XMR: 800,000,000
Price (from Poloniex):
BCN: 0.00000007
XMR: 0.0029
Mining revenue adjusted for the difficulty = (Daily emission / difficulty) * Price:
BCN: 0.0000000846318306326
XMR: 0.0000000868489583333
Difficulty is already adjusted for different block time, so no need to discount on it. This makes XMR a more profitable target for botnet owners. And yesterday when I did the same calculations, XMR price was higher, BCN difficulty 20M lower. That is why it was 10% higher for XMR.
Do you really think that a botnet is just a mining gear? And rape is just a form of sex, right? Anyway, I'm pretty sure that botnet owners don't hold the coins they've mined as there are risks associated with the waiting game and you might have used your botnet for other purposes instead.
Your rape analogy is a bit strained, but to strain it further, if a rape occurs and a child is born, do you continue to associate the child with the rape? Coins are coins, and where they come from doesn't really matter to anyone else. That's what fungibility is all about.
Coins generated are either sold by the miner (almost always in the case of large scale professional miners) or held (sometimes by small scale miners and occasionally by large investors who have their own mining operations). That is the distincton that matters in terms of economics, and even that one doesn't always matter (if there are investors who prefer to buy than mine), as I explained earlier.
What I was trying to say is that botnets should be considered unworthy and frowned upon for CPU coins as they rip off regular miners. And they're illegal by the way.
And yes, if there are a lot of botnet miners selling, the supply side will prevail over the demand and the coin is likely to have a negative trend (recheck XMR price charts of the last week). And this is exactly the thought I've been trying to tell you for the last 4 pages.