-snip-
Thanks very much for your elaborate answer. I will try your suggestion of comparing a week, but shouldn't we take in mind that price changes and market volatility itself also play a huge role (biggest?) in the final week outcome in result. This makes comparing theoretically impossible, we need to have the exact same situation again, which is impossible.
yes, you can't be completely accurate. you have to make volatility indices regarding what actually happened with any coin. Your rig might not allow it, but you could also split your rigs up to parallel mine and have more reference points for a week (given two similar rigs, was one strategy better or worse).
A week is also not enough time to have mined some of each or see lots of swings / pumps+dumps.
For example, you could just be "most profitable" if you can't sell consistently in time and high enough with just sticking with one pool rather than switching to chase profitability, especially if you don't want to wait.
Still the question about the AutoSell rule remains: I don't understand the options, could you maybe explain them? And which one is the best for auto-selling?
my assumptiona are, from least amount potentially gained to highest:
immediate complete sell: goes down all of the buy orders and fills the highest ones it can. No idea what happens regarding timing: what if it is going through this process and selling 1 at 10, then 5, then 1 but someone posts a buy for 11 where there's a sell wall of 10,000 and you only have 1? Assumption is that it detects you will not be able to fulfill this order and keeps going at the highest orders you can fulfill immediately. What if someone posts at 3 that you can fulfill, will it go up the cost to fulfill it? Dunno.
top buy bid: posts your order at whatever the most someone will pay for any amount is. If the highest buy is 1, but someone only wants .01 of it at 1... and you have 10, you will post 10 for sale at 1.
top sell bid: posts your order at whatever the least someone will sell for any amount is. (i'd prefer this be called the lowest sell bid, but I could be wrong about this description). if the top sell bid is 1 and there are 10,000 of it for sale at 1, you will post 10 for sale at 1. If there are .000001 for sale at 1, you will post 10 for sale at 1.
second highest sell bid: posts your order at whatever the 2nd least someone will sell for any amount. If there is a huge sell wall at 10, and the next highest sell is 11. you will post your order at 11. Of course what might also happen is a bunch of tiny sales before the wall and yours would be the 2nd highest of those.
Assuming 100% of your orders sell, you would end up with the most return in that order, the balance is that you actually might not see a sale with those options ever. and in the case of hitting a peak or upswing, you would be most profitable selling asap rather than missing the upswing due to risking that the upswing will keep going up.
Another concept is that holding these for long periods of time will increase their values more than converting them even in the near short term will ever, especially if you wait for obvious pumps/bubbles. "All boats rise with the tide..." The valuations some of these coins that have no unique utility is phenomenal when you consider them relative to bitcoins historical value. they are worth a lot, really quickly, just due to their proximity to bitcoin as a technological advancement. The flipside of that idea is that we're just seeing them in a bubble and they're just a distraction away from the fact that coins should just be considered their hashing algo, more than 1 of each method is redundant even regarding tangential functionality.
the key here is that these are essentially conveniences and you are taxed for using them. my question / assertion would be that the fun part is having lots of different coins and ways to maximize profitability, why omit yourself from that? Multipool tries its best to get you the most for your rate.
if the % return you're getting in some timeframe or with some method is clearly lower than if you had just stuck with one coin, or if you aren't around to micromanage a great conversion opportunity (swap coin x for coin y and move it from exchange z to exchange a, get the most profit that way). these are all factors that dampen the utility of instantly selling from a pool.