Giveaway threads are not allowed - page 45.

roundrobin

full member

Activity: 203

Merit: 100

Quote from: shogdite on January 27, 2014, 09:11:21 AM

Think it's a good idea. I've been trying to research a few of the alt currencies and it's a nightmare sifting through all the giveaway threads.

No. Moving giveaways to a new subforum is a good idea. Killing them is rejecting their promotion and marketing, and that's not a good idea.

KeyserSozeMC

hero member

Activity: 742

Merit: 500

I'm dying.

Quote from: stompix on January 27, 2014, 08:58:10 AM

Quote from: KeyserSozeMC on January 27, 2014, 08:42:25 AM

Quote from: stompix on January 27, 2014, 08:35:00 AM

Well , I support this. I clearly do. Why?
Cause the alt section is a mess.

Theymos did something for the alts , he has allowed sub forums , even though it's bitcointalk not altcointalk.
And the result :?

From one huge mess 4 new huge messes.
Mining pools , giveaways , new coins , second launch announcements in the announcement thread.
Mining pools in all the subforums.
Lots of coins have two threads in both ann and in the main subforum.
Giveaways everywhere , and as far as I've seen most of them are scams used to spam the forum to attract people to that coin.

And we should not even talk about random newbies with 1 post that infiltrate the other forums with "buy xxx " "xx coin is the solution".

I know it seems like a harsh decision but some rules need to be enforced here.

He's earning money from that.

Why didn't they think about that when they ''allowed'' (rofl) alt-coins in the forum?

You know , you're making some assumption here.
I hope you're referring to traffic gained not to "%x , percentage of something" cause that might look like a bribery taking part.

Care to clear things up?
Also with an activity as big as mine (or should I say small as) you're pretty demanding.

Of course I'm talking about traffic. What else could I be talking about?

I'm not demanding, I just want this forum get on its feet with alts. I love bct, I wouldn't damage it.

I do ''business'' on this forum. I'm interested to advertise myself here as well. I even offered my own money for a new HDD/SSD if they can't support a new section

shogdite

hero member

Activity: 798

Merit: 1000

LIR Dev. www.letitride.io

Think it's a good idea. I've been trying to research a few of the alt currencies and it's a nightmare sifting through all the giveaway threads.

stompix

legendary

Activity: 2912

Merit: 6403

Blackjack.fun

Quote from: KeyserSozeMC on January 27, 2014, 08:42:25 AM

Quote from: stompix on January 27, 2014, 08:35:00 AM

Well , I support this. I clearly do. Why?
Cause the alt section is a mess.

Theymos did something for the alts , he has allowed sub forums , even though it's bitcointalk not altcointalk.
And the result :?

From one huge mess 4 new huge messes.
Mining pools , giveaways , new coins , second launch announcements in the announcement thread.
Mining pools in all the subforums.
Lots of coins have two threads in both ann and in the main subforum.
Giveaways everywhere , and as far as I've seen most of them are scams used to spam the forum to attract people to that coin.

And we should not even talk about random newbies with 1 post that infiltrate the other forums with "buy xxx " "xx coin is the solution".

I know it seems like a harsh decision but some rules need to be enforced here.

He's earning money from that.

Why didn't they think about that when they ''allowed'' (rofl) alt-coins in the forum?

You know , you're making some assumption here.
I hope you're referring to traffic gained not to "%x , percentage of something" cause that might look like a bribery taking part.

Care to clear things up?
Also with an activity as big as mine (or should I say small as) you're pretty demanding.

KeyserSozeMC

hero member

Activity: 742

Merit: 500

I'm dying.

I'm expecting for an answer from theymos or anyone else from the staff.

People are waiting me to send them the coins I promised.

I don't want to get banned because I sent coins to people, nor I want those people get banned.

roundrobin

full member

Activity: 203

Merit: 100

I don't see how this decision is promoting or helping cryptocurrency the least. It's just counter-intuitive, and a showcase of tiny-minded BOFHism. To increase awareness and use of cryptocurrency people MUST be allowed to promote, as long as they are not scamming miners or traders for their resources. I was spending a lot of time trying to promote a specific coin (which I don't dare to mention here in fear of getting banned by the trigger-happy admin) through a giveaway of my mined earnings, but now me and others are suddenly disallowed this participation.

You should make a subforum for it instead of just putting a gag on everyone, that way you get a cleaner announcement forum and we get to keep our ability to promote coins.

pineapples

legendary

Activity: 1204

Merit: 1000

to your stations, man the pineapples!!!

make a sub forum, move the clutter to somewhere where it aint clutter no more.

unless we wants all serious face :|

--
mayhaps even give someone a job of moderating the giveaways, limiting who can create threads etc .. lot of crap giveaways ? shut them down.

KeyserSozeMC

hero member

Activity: 742

Merit: 500

I'm dying.

Quote from: stompix on January 27, 2014, 08:35:00 AM

Well , I support this. I clearly do. Why?
Cause the alt section is a mess.

Theymos did something for the alts , he has allowed sub forums , even though it's bitcointalk not altcointalk.
And the result :?

From one huge mess 4 new huge messes.
Mining pools , giveaways , new coins , second launch announcements in the announcement thread.
Mining pools in all the subforums.
Lots of coins have two threads in both ann and in the main subforum.
Giveaways everywhere , and as far as I've seen most of them are scams used to spam the forum to attract people to that coin.

And we should not even talk about random newbies with 1 post that infiltrate the other forums with "buy xxx " "xx coin is the solution".

I know it seems like a harsh decision but some rules need to be enforced here.

He's earning money from that.

Why didn't they think about that when they ''allowed'' (rofl) alt-coins in the forum?

stompix

legendary

Activity: 2912

Merit: 6403

Blackjack.fun

Well , I support this. I clearly do. Why?
Cause the alt section is a mess.

Theymos did something for the alts , he has allowed sub forums , even though it's bitcointalk not altcointalk.
And the result :?

From one huge mess 4 new huge messes.
Mining pools , giveaways , new coins , second launch announcements in the announcement thread.
Mining pools in all the subforums.
Lots of coins have two threads in both ann and in the main subforum.
Giveaways everywhere , and as far as I've seen most of them are scams used to spam the forum to attract people to that coin.

And we should not even talk about random newbies with 1 post that infiltrate the other forums with "buy xxx " "xx coin is the solution".

I know it seems like a harsh decision but some rules need to be enforced here.

iGotSpots

legendary

Activity: 2548

Merit: 1054

CPU Web Mining 🕸️ on webmining.io

This is fucking retarded and the admins or posters that support it are stupid

The spam here is bad, but restricting it this way just shows how little you guys understand

KrvnoZrnce

sr. member

Activity: 280

Merit: 250

Why should I support killing giveaway threads (which are pain in the arse) when admins aren't doing shit with reported people and posts?
We report spammers, scammers and junk posts and you don't care a bit and now you wan't to remove some of the spam with killing giveaway threads?

It's a matter of principle, you should fight all spam instead of thinking of a reason to close big part of altcoins because they are threatening bitcoin (they're not, but there are some crazy people out there thinking they know best).

Don't get me wrong, I'm all for shutting down giveaways on this forum but will not support it until I see actual scammers and spammers being banned from the forum after being reported to moderator...

KeyserSozeMC

hero member

Activity: 742

Merit: 500

I'm dying.

Quote from: cranial.nerve on January 27, 2014, 08:07:09 AM

Anyway it doesn't work.

I've post 20+ messages to giveaways yesterday, only 3 give me coins. Every DOGE coins giveaway - just a flood section, there are no coins, nothing received.

You're posting in the wrong threads buddy!

I have 1500+ followers which receive free coins everyday!

https://twitter.com/ThisWeeksCoin

cranial.nerve

newbie

Activity: 39

Merit: 0

Anyway it doesn't work.

I've post 20+ messages to giveaways yesterday, only 3 give me coins. Every DOGE coins giveaway - just a flood section, there are no coins, nothing received.

lasciv

full member

Activity: 126

Merit: 100

If you ban giveaways people will just rename it and spam again.

Subforum would be more effective.

Kiss

KeyserSozeMC

hero member

Activity: 742

Merit: 500

I'm dying.

Quote from: Kluge on January 27, 2014, 07:58:25 AM

Quote from: Gazza1 on January 27, 2014, 07:37:52 AM

Are you saying we can't give people bounties for doing jobs for the coin? that doesn't make sense, that's what this game is all about. I sure hope I'm misreading that.

Why do donators want the altcoin section gone? All they have to do is NOT visit the subforum. It's called bookmarking your fav subforms.

Any of you Web designer forum making guys, it sounds like we need to get prepared to take our house somewhere else.

Bitcoin is great and we want it to thrive, but altcoins make us all a lot of money were as with bitcoin eventually only a top handful of groups are going to be making money mining. Altcoins are making a lot of people's dreams come true. People that really need it.

Altcoin subforum has useful information. Altcoin subforum is heavily populated by giveaway threads, reducing usefulness of subforum to those without desire for $.00005 worth of NewAltCoin. (among garbage coin announcements, but it's probably impossible to make an effective, binary ruleset on what is and isn't acceptable)

Giveaway sub-subforum solution is acceptable, I think. There may also be a correlation between account sales (which is allowed because it's very difficult to effectively enforce a ban against) and giveaway threads, but who really cares about that? There may also be more "ideological" reasons for this move (preventing pump&dumps)... don't really care about those.

BTC was pumped and dumped. BTC was the first coin which was pumped and dumped ever. There are threads with BTC giveaways. I find it useless, if other altcoin giveaways are useless.

There must be one giveaway section for btc/alts.

''$.00005 worth of NewAltCoin''.. I gave more than 10k USD in giveaways.

I'm offering my help.

noedelx

full member

Activity: 140

Merit: 100

oh that explains why my thread got locked ( i made a new one without knowing this rule) il lock the new one aswel

Kluge

donator

Activity: 1218

Merit: 1015

Quote from: Gazza1 on January 27, 2014, 07:37:52 AM

Are you saying we can't give people bounties for doing jobs for the coin? that doesn't make sense, that's what this game is all about. I sure hope I'm misreading that.

Why do donators want the altcoin section gone? All they have to do is NOT visit the subforum. It's called bookmarking your fav subforms.

Any of you Web designer forum making guys, it sounds like we need to get prepared to take our house somewhere else.

Bitcoin is great and we want it to thrive, but altcoins make us all a lot of money were as with bitcoin eventually only a top handful of groups are going to be making money mining. Altcoins are making a lot of people's dreams come true. People that really need it.

Altcoin subforum has useful information. Altcoin subforum is heavily populated by giveaway threads, reducing usefulness of subforum to those without desire for $.00005 worth of NewAltCoin. (among garbage coin announcements, but it's probably impossible to make an effective, binary ruleset on what is and isn't acceptable)

Giveaway sub-subforum solution is acceptable, I think. There may also be a correlation between account sales (which is allowed because it's very difficult to effectively enforce a ban against) and giveaway threads, but who really cares about that? There may also be more "ideological" reasons for this move (preventing pump&dumps)... don't really care about those.

Sberbank

newbie

Activity: 42

Merit: 0

Of course that cryptocoins have no sense nor future if they can not be advertised!!

Gazza1

full member

Activity: 238

Merit: 100

Are you saying we can't give people bounties for doing jobs for the coin? that doesn't make sense, that's what this game is all about. I sure hope I'm misreading that. Or are you just talking about dedicated random giveaway threads?

Why do donators want the altcoin section gone? All they have to do is NOT visit the subforum. It's called bookmarking your fav subforms.

Any of you Web designer forum making guys, it sounds like we need to get prepared to take our house somewhere else.

Bitcoin is great and we want it to thrive, but altcoins make us all a lot of money were as with bitcoin eventually only a top handful of groups are going to be making money mining. Altcoins are making a lot of people's dreams come true. People that really need it.

KeyserSozeMC

hero member

Activity: 742

Merit: 500

I'm dying.

Here's a solution. https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=434671.new#new

Topic: Giveaway threads are not allowed - page 45. (Read 1044392 times)