Pages:
Author

Topic: [Guide] Dogie's Comprehensive Power Supply Analysis - page 7. (Read 23161 times)

legendary
Activity: 1666
Merit: 1183
dogiecoin.com
This is a great thread and quite necessary.  I even thought about doing one up myself but because I'm so new I figured people might think I have some agenda or something.

jonnyguru reviews help too.

This.  Big this.  Especially for people who want to later re-task the power supply for something else.

I'm only in the US market so all my info will be slanted towards that.  Specially slanted towards a ratio of performance and efficiency:value.  Warranty also important factor as well.  I also don't hesitate to buy products on rebate or refurbished hardware from well known suppliers so I'll throw that into the mix as well.  The prices I've listed are the "deal" prices; not necessarily the everyday prices.

Also I think some sort of number-letter coding for which mining hardware each supply is confirmed to work with would be very helpful.  Especially for n00bz.  Grin  Like maybe 3B if it can run 3 Blades or 2C if it can run 2 Cubes for example.

Do you want to list hardware confirmed to have issues of sorts?  For example, I listed the SS-760XP2 but at stock it will not keep Cubes powered on, even just a single.  Likely a no-load/overload shutdown protection of some sort that could be solved with a capacitor but I haven't that yet tested.

Below are a few of the power supplies I've personally tested with mining hardware that aren't currently on your list.  I've already tested a bunch that already were on the list so no need to replicate those here.

*snip*
Quoted. Can you delete the table out of yours, otherwise it won't 'update' as the rest of the OP is changed. I'll delete it out of mine once it stops being useful.
member
Activity: 98
Merit: 10
Caveat Emptor

Regularly Updated Pricing Table:

BrandSeriesCapacity
(Manual)
Peak
(W)
12V
Rail (A)
No.
Rails
PCI-E
Plugs
Modular
Cables
Noise @
100% (dbA)
Eff. @ 100%
230V (%)
Warranty
(years)
MHCPricing: Low/Avg/HighNETDAMFrysOther
CorsairCX430W473W32A11No30.585.33Yes$20AR / $31AR / $452520---
CorsairCX500W550W38A12No3484.93Yes$30AR / $50AR / $65-----
CorsairCX600W660W46A12No3484.93Yes$28AR / $60AR / $7838----
CorsairCXM500W550W38A12Semi32.4853Yes$30AR / $52AR / $74-34---
CorsairCXM600W660W46A12Semi32.284.93Yes$40AR / $60AR / $91-45---
CorsairAX850W935W70A14Yes33.989.67Yes$108(R)---108-
CorsairRM550W605W45.8A12Yes21.189.55Yes$70AR / $102AR / $110--80--
DellZ750PZ750P750W+62A14*Yes*Variable*90.0+N/AYes$53 / $70 / $85----70
SeasonicPlatinum760W800W+63A16Yes-90.0+7NO$100AR / $158AR / $175-----
SeasonicG750W787W62A16Semi~38~885Yes$80AR / $123AR / $16780----
XFXPro550W676W44A12No-825Yes$21AR / $42AR / $60-----
XFXPro750W834W62A14No-825Yes$70AR / $94AR / $105--75--

* Requires a Server Power Supply Interface Board

Key:
  • AR - After Rebate
  • AVG - Average Price
  • H - Highest Price
  • L - Lowest Price
  • MHC - Mining Hardware Compatible and Confirmed
  • (R) - Refurbished/Recertified

Vendors:
  • NE - Newegg
  • TD - TigerDirect
  • AM - Amazon
  • Frys - Fry's Electronics
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 1001
legendary
Activity: 1666
Merit: 1183
dogiecoin.com
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 1001
Very nice!!

Can you add how many PCIExpress cables also.Been having a helluva time finding 500+ watt PSU's with at least 2 separate PCIE cables (not connectors) for my Ants  Roll Eyes

Decided on the Corsair CX600,I'll verify if it indeed has 2 seperate cables  Wink

I know for sure,cause I have these, Corsair CX750M has 2 cables with 1-6pin & 1-6+2 on each.Can power one Ant.

Corsair RM850M has only 3 (not 4) PCIE cables with 1-6pin & 1-6+2 on each,so can only power 1 1/2 Ants  Roll Eyes Won't be getting this again  Sad

A PSU I didn't think I'd like,but ended up I do like,is the Ultra X4 850 watt modular (60 amp,single rail too Grin ),it has up to 6 separate PCIE cables with 1-6pin or 1-6+2 on each separate cable  Shocked  
But with only 850 watts it's good for 2 Ants  Grin

It's from WAY back when,but still up to date for specs:
http://www.tweaknews.net/reviews/ultra_x4_850_watt_power_supply/

http://www.ultraproducts.com/applications/campaigns/campaigntemplate.asp?CampaignID=1111

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/searchtools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=4558892

Thanks Dogie!!!  Wink
legendary
Activity: 1764
Merit: 1006
jonnyguru reviews help too.                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         
hero member
Activity: 1249
Merit: 506
nm .........
legendary
Activity: 1666
Merit: 1183
dogiecoin.com
No SeaSonic?  They are the standard.  They actually build their powersupplies unlike every company on the list. Smiley
I'll get Seasonic added in the next revision then. I was waiting for suggestions rather than assuming what the US market likes to use, EU and US PSU preferences are very different. For instance over here, we don't get PCP&C at all Sad
donator
Activity: 1218
Merit: 1079
Gerald Davis
No SeaSonic?  They are the standard.  They actually build their powersupplies unlike every company on the list. Smiley
hero member
Activity: 1249
Merit: 506
Very nice Dogie! Your write ups are hands down the best and a staple to the community. Thanks for taking time out of your day to help us all.
legendary
Activity: 1666
Merit: 1183
dogiecoin.com
Reserved
legendary
Activity: 1666
Merit: 1183
dogiecoin.com
Reserved
legendary
Activity: 1666
Merit: 1183
dogiecoin.com
Last Updates

Changelog 02/25/2014
  • Added Seasonic range
  • Prices updated

Changelog 09/14/2014
  • Fixed corsair links

Changelog 09/22/2014
  • List now spreads across two pages due to post character limit
  • Removed some unnecessary decimal places
  • Fixed some prices
  • Fixed column spacing
legendary
Activity: 1666
Merit: 1183
dogiecoin.com
Brand          Series               Capacity
(Manual)
   
Peak
(W)
       
12V
Rail (A)
No.
Rails
PCI-E
Plugs
   
Modular
Cables?
 
Noise @
100% (dbA)
Eff. @ 100%
230V (%)
Warranty
(years)
Dogie's
Rating
Buy here
SeasonicG360W378W16A11Semi3888540.8$54.99
450W472W37A12Semi3888560.1$74.99
550W577W45A12Semi3888560.9$85.99
650W682W54A14Semi3888565.4$104.99
750W787W62A16Semi3888563.5$129.99
   
SeasonicM12II Bronze520W520W40A22Semi4384540.2$88.14
620W620W48A22Semi4384544.7$89.99
650W650W53A14Semi4386558.3$99.99
750W750W62A14Semi4386561.7$109.99
850W850W70A14Semi4386548.6$150.64
   
SeasonicS12II Bronze380W380W27A21No3886547.3$49.99
430W430W30A22No3886551.5$59.99
520W520W40A22No3886542.7$88.14
620W620W48A22No3886547.5$89.99
   
SeasonicS12G450W472W37A12No3589554.6$80.34
550W577W45A12No3589559.5$85.56
650W682W54A14No3589560.8$109.85
750W787W62A14No3589576.9$99.99



If you have a PSU request, I will try and add it. Post here or feel free to PM me.


                                 
                                                 Advertised sites are not endorsed and may be unsafe, untrustworthy, or illegal in your jurisdiction. Advertise here.

                                 
                                                 Advertised sites are not endorsed and may be unsafe, untrustworthy, or illegal in your jurisdiction. Advertise here.

                                 
                                                 Advertised sites are not endorsed and may be unsafe, untrustworthy, or illegal in your jurisdiction. Advertise here.

                                 
                                                 Advertised sites are not endorsed and may be unsafe, untrustworthy, or illegal in your jurisdiction. Advertise here.

                                 
                                                 Advertised sites are not endorsed and may be unsafe, untrustworthy, or illegal in your jurisdiction. Advertise here.
legendary
Activity: 1666
Merit: 1183
dogiecoin.com
Dogie's Miner Setup Guides:
    ASICMiner Blade
ASICMiner Cube
ASICMiner Tube
ASICMiner Prisma
Avalon Avalon2
Avalon Avalon3
Avalon Avalon4
Avalon Avalon6
SpondooliesTech SP10
SpondooliesTech SP20
SpondooliesTech SP30
SpondooliesTech SP35
Technobit HEX16B
Technobit HEX8A1
Technobit HEX4M
Technobit 2HEX4M
KNCMiner Saturn/Jupiter
Bitmain AntMiner S1
Bitmain AntMiner S2
Bitmain AntMiner S3
Bitmain AntMiner S4
Bitmain AntMiner S4+
Bitmain AntMiner S5
Bitmain AntMiner S7
Bitmain AntMiner C1
Bitmain AntMiner U3
RockMiner R-Box
RockMiner New R-Box
RockMiner R3-Box
RockMiner T1
HashCoins Apollo
HashCoins Ares
NonceTech Sampo
Yiazo YBF
BTCGarden AMV1
Bitmine Coincraft Desk V2
HashRatio Tsunami
XBTech Pacific 1250
BitCrane T-110
Black Arrow Prospero X1
AMT 1.25TH
C-Scape HexFury USB
C-Scape BiFury USB
MoonlightMiner NanoFury II USB
    Gigampz PSU breakout board


    Guide meta thread
    DefaultTrust Visualisation
    Power Supply analysis guide
    Manufacturer trustworthiness guide
___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________



Introduction
I'm getting questions around what PSUs are best and company offerings are often overwhelming. Corsair for example sells TEN different models. This guide breaks down each PSU by their important specifications, and then uses a propriety algorithm to determine the best.

Dogie's Rating
   90+ = Excellent PSU or opportunistic price
   80+ = Very good, second tier PSUs
   70+ = Mid tier PSU, not as good buys
   60+ = Very price inefficient or horrific specification PSUs
   59- = Avoid, there will be better options.
   
Ratings
Brand          Series               Capacity
(Manual)
   
Peak
(W)
       
12V
Rail (A)
No.
Rails
PCI-E
Plugs
   
Modular
Cables?
 
Noise @
100% (dbA)
Eff. @ 100%
230V (%)
Warranty
(years)
Dogie's
Rating
Buy here
CorsairCX430W473W32A11No30.585.3379.3$39.99
500W550W38A12No3484.9378.4$49.99
600W660W46A12No3484.9375$59.99
750W825W62A12No39.987378.2$69.99
   
CorsairCXM430W473W32A11Semi3185.3370.1$49.99
500W550W38A12Semi32.485372.2$59.99
600W660W46A12Semi32.284.9376.6$64.99
CorsairCX430W473W32A11No30.585.3379.3$39.99
   
CorsairCSM450W495W35A11Semi3892364.2$59.99
550W605W43A14Semi3892386.1$69.99
650W715W51A14Semi3892372.7$93.95
750W825W62A14Semi3892367.7$119.99
850W935W71A14Semi3892363.2$139.99
   
CorsairAX750W825W62A14Yes37.490.3761.5$159.99
760W836W63A14Yes2491.8778.8$149.99
850W936W70A16Yes33.989.6762.9$189.99
860W946W71A16Yes2989.4774.7$169.99
1200W1320W100A16Yes31.690.3777.3$219.99
   
CorsairAXi760W836W63AToggle8Yes23.592.4776.6$184.99
860W946W72AToggle8Yes28.892767.1$219.99
1200W1320W100AToggle8Yes22.992.4771.3$301.99
   
CorsairHX650W715W54A12Semi46.989.7756.9$109.99
750W825W62A14Semi30.889.1767.6$139.99
850W935W70A16Semi3289.6765.8$169.99
1050W1155W87A16Semi40.189.6753.1$219.99
   
CorsairRM450W495W37A12Yes21.189.7559.4$104.99
550W605W46A12Yes21.189.5577.2$94.99
650W715W54A14Yes24.889.3583.3$108.99
750W825W63A14Yes2390.45100$109.99
850W935W71A16Yes2389.9590.3$137.99
1000W1100W83A18Yes26.789.4591.3$159.99
   
CorsairTXM650W715W54A12Semi33.185.4566.3$95.99
750W825W62A14Semi30.487.4594.2$89.99
850W935W70A14Semi39.286.5565.5$129.99
   
Brand          Series               Capacity
(Manual)
   
Peak
(W)
       
12V
Rail (A)
No.
Rails
PCI-E
Plugs
   
Modular
Cables?
 
Noise @
100% (dbA)
Eff. @ 100%
230V (%)
Warranty
(years)
Dogie's
Rating
Buy here
CorsairTX650W715W54A12No33.184564.8$79.99
750W825W62A14No30.487585.3$89.99
850W935W70A14No39.285569.3$99.99
   
CorsairGS600W660W49A12No42.385.2365.3$69.99
700W770W58A12No45.886346.4$109.99
800W880W66A14No47.485.7356.2$119.99
   
EVGAClassified1200W1200W100A615Semi4085535.6$279.99
1500W1650W124AToggle19Yes4090560.6$349.99
   
EVGASuperNOVA G2750W750W62A14Yes40901082.3$112.99
850W850W71A16Yes40901079.2$139.99
1000W1000W83A18Yes40901078.8$164.95
1300W1300W108A18Yes40901095.1$169.99
1600W1600W133A114Yes40901063.1$329.99
   
EVGABronze500W500W40A12No4085367$50.99
600W600W49A12No4085356.3$70.15
   
EVGA80 PLUS430W430W34A11No4080355.6$39.99
500W500W40A12No4080367.4$44.99
   
SeasonicPlatinum660W693W55A14Yes3890.5755.4$149.99
760W798W63A14Yes3891747.7$199.99
860W903W71A16Yes3891.3742.9$262.55
1000W1050W83A16Yes3891741.2$304.98
   
SeasonicX650W682.5W54A14Yes3889.5752$149.99
750W787.5W62A14Yes3890756$159.99
850W892.5W70A16Yes3890758.9$179.99
1050W1102.5W87A16Yes3890761.6$204.13
1250W1312.5W104A18Yes3890737.5$399.99




Continued...
Pages:
Jump to: